Staffers with Mary Peltola’s U.S. Senate campaign and national Democrats were involved in recruiting efforts that led to the namesake challenger to Sen. Dan Sullivan appearing on the ballot in one of the nation’s most closely followed races, The New York Times reported Wednesday.
The efforts, which allegedly involved the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee, were part of a broad Democratic campaign that began last year and sought to recruit spoilers onto the ballot who could potentially siphon votes away from the Republican incumbent, the Times reported.
The campaign for Peltola, a Democrat, has repeatedly denied any involvement in the candidacy of Dan J. Sullivan, a retired teacher from the Southeast Alaska town of Petersburg. Dan. J. Sullivan registered as a Republican when he entered the race to challenge the incumbent senator, fueling accusations from state and national Republicans who have said he is running a campaign in an effort to deceive voters.
The Petersburg Sullivan has since switched his party affiliation from Republican to undeclared, according to his request for an absentee ballot in the primary election, the Alaska Beacon reported Monday.
Elisa Rios, Peltola’s longtime aide who was fired amid a staff shake-up shortly before the August primary election, told the Times that a Democratic operative from the Lower 48 had hunted for Dan Sullivans who could challenge the senator, according to the story.
The operative, an expert in secret ballot maneuvers who was brought into the picture by the Democratic senatorial committee, found a willing participant in the Petersburg Sullivan, the Times reported.
Rios said Peltola was aware of the efforts but not directly involved, according to the report, which was based on interviews with a dozen sources that the Times said had knowledge of, were involved in or were approached for the recruiting effort. The Times also reported that Rios sought to retract her comments last week as it was preparing the article for publication.
Rios did not respond to a request for an interview from the Daily News.
The Times published the story with just six days remaining before Tuesday’s general election. Polls show that Peltola has a shot at winning Alaska’s tight Senate race, which may help determine which party holds control of the chamber. As a result, it has become one of the most hotly contested races in the nation.
Republican President Donald Trump, an ally of Sullivan, last week ordered the Justice Department to file a lawsuit to block certification of the Senate race if the Petersburg Sullivan’s appearance on the ballot fosters voter confusion that leads to the GOP senator’s loss.
In response to the lawsuit brought against Alaska election officials and boards, Peltola and the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee filed a motion to intervene in the case and to stop the Trump administration’s effort to block election results certification. On Monday, the state of Alaska also asked the federal court to dismiss the federal government’s lawsuit, arguing that it “has no legal basis.”
The Justice Department withdrew its opposition to the Peltola campaign’s motion to join the lawsuit on Wednesday, citing “the change in circumstances” due to the Times’ reporting. The Justice Department’s short filing said it hopes to use the Peltola campaign and Democratic committee’s involvement in the lawsuit to further investigate the allegations in the article.
“The United States intends to seek expedited discovery from the Campaign regarding the reported conspiracy, including as to whether the Campaign attempted to deceive the Court by seeking an expedited ruling on a motion to dismiss when the Campaign may have been aware of the New York Times reporting before it was published,” the filing said.
Harry Child, a spokesperson for the Alaskans for Mary campaign, said in an email Wednesday that the campaign has no involvement with either Sullivan campaign.
“Like Mary, our campaign is focused on lowering costs and fixing the rigged system in DC,” the statement said.
The national Democratic committee did not respond to requests for comment for this article, but in the Times story it denied participating in the effort to recruit spoilers.
Peltola’s campaign and the committee did not address a detailed list of questions, the Times article said.
Murkowski: ‘Lies and coverups’
Dan J. Sullivan, the Petersburg challenger, did not respond to a request for comment for this article. He also declined to comment in the Times article.
The Petersburg candidate, who filed to run in May shortly before the state’s filing deadline, has maintained that he was not recruited by Democrats and instead is running because he disagrees with the senator’s policies and actions.
He earned 2.5% of the primary vote, enough support that Republicans believe his presence could sway the outcome of the race.
Nate Adams, the spokesperson for Sen. Sullivan’s campaign, said in a prepared statement Wednesday that “Alaskans deserve to know the truth.”
“Mary Peltola, her campaign, and her senior advisors colluded with the DSCC, national Democrat lawyers, and Alaska Democrat operatives to recruit a candidate to deliberately deceive and confuse voters, and then repeatedly lied about it,” Adams said. “We always knew this was a concerted effort to deceive voters, and Mary Peltola was hoping it would stay hidden until after the election.”
Republican U.S. Sen. Lisa Murkowski, who has endorsed the incumbent Sullivan, said in a statement that “ballot-stacking should have no place in our electoral process” and that candidates should run on their policy ideas and accomplishments.
“By contrast, recruiting candidates to manipulate the field and influence voting outcomes is simply wrong,” Murkowski said. “Alaskans deserve the honest truth from Mary and her campaign — what has been revealed is a pattern of lies and coverups and a culture of deception that belongs nowhere in our elections or among our elected officials.”
Trump also weighed in Wednesday, saying, “Mary Peltola should resign from the race. I think she should be prosecuted criminally for what she did.”
“This guy Dan Sullivan just ran against Dan Sullivan,” Trump said. “It turned out it was a scheme by the Democrats.”
Jenny-Marie Stryker, executive directorof the Alaska Democratic Party, said the group is “in no way affiliated” with either of the Sullivan campaigns.
She had no comment when asked if the group was aware of the Democratic senate committee’s efforts to boost the Petersburg Sullivan.
Part of a broader spoiler effort
Partisan attempts to influence ballot choices is nothing new.
Republicans nationwide and in Alaska have been involved in efforts, including this year, to boost spoilers on the ballot as well.
Ahead of Alaska’s U.S. Senate primary, the Republican-aligned Fair Deal Alaska super PAC spent large sums of money to support Democrat Carol Hafner and Green Party candidate Richard Grayson, and to draw votes away from Peltola. Both Hafner and Grayson are fringe candidates who don’t live in Alaska.
During the 2024 U.S. House race, in which then-Rep. Peltola lost to Republican challenger Nick Begich, Republicans in Alaska supported the candidacy of spoiler candidate Eric Hafner — a Democrat who is serving a prison sentence outside Alaska — to also draw votes from Peltola. He is the son of 2026 Senate candidate Carol.
The Alaska Supreme Court determined in 2024 that Eric Hafner could remain on that year’s ballot. He appears on the ballot again this year in the U.S. House race.
Earlier this year, the state Supreme Court also allowed the Petersburg Sullivan to remain on the ballot, upholding a lower court’s ruling that candidates seeking office have no constitutional obligation to demonstrate that they are running in “good-faith.”
Minor candidates describe interactions with operative
The Times article reported on efforts by Peltola’s campaign and the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee, which works to elect Democrats to Senate seats, to recruit multiple spoiler candidates onto the primary ballot.
It also detailed an effort by the Democratic political operative to encourage David Leslie, a Fairbanks progressive, to drop off the ballot after the August primary.
Leslie, a Democrat, had finished fourth in the primary, making him eligible to appear before voters in the general election. He agreed to step aside, which elevated the next finisher in the primary, Gerald Heikes — a Republican and perennial long-shot candidate — onto the ballot in the general election.
Leslie said in an interview Wednesday that the call from the operative was only one of the reasons he dropped out of the race.
But Leslie said he was concerned that remaining on the ballot as a Democrat would remove votes from Peltola, causing her to lose and Republicans to remain in control of the Senate.
Leslie said he still plans to vote for Peltola, but he is frustrated that the efforts to recruit spoilers is overshadowing issues such as the need for Trump to be impeached for “corruption and his abuse of power.”
“We should be talking to our friends and neighbors about issues that matter, rather than trying to manipulate a system,” he said.
Heikes, who received 1% of the vote in the primary, said Wednesday that he was recruited by someone from the Lower 48 to run against Sullivan early this year, after he had initially sought to run against Begich in the U.S. House race.
Political groups have so far spent more than $2 million in ads to boost Heikes, one of which is heavily funded by progressive organization Sixteen Thirty Fund, based in Washington, D.C. Social media ads for the candidate touted Heikes as a more socially conservative alternative to the incumbent Sullivan and encourage voters to rank only Heikes on their ballot, instead of ranking multiple choices.
“The man said, ‘We can’t help your campaign, but we’ll back you, and we’ll take care of some advertising,” Heikes said about the unidentified person who recruited him to run for Senate.
Heikes said PACs have used his image in ads in the race, but he’s not sure how they got those images.
“I’m not really all that in tune with what’s going on, except for how I see the biblical part of this thing playing out,” he said. “God will choose the winner and the losers,” he said.
Impact on the Trump administration lawsuit
Whether the details of the Times story will affect the recently filed Trump administration lawsuit is unclear.
The lawsuit seeks to prevent Alaska from certifying the election results if Sen. Sullivan narrowly loses.
The case is moving quickly before Judge Sharon Gleason in U.S. District Court in Alaska.
Legal experts have questioned the suit’s legal basis, arguing that an investigation into voters’ intent after an election is impractical.
Scott Kendall — an Anchorage attorney and an architect of Alaska’s ranked choice voting system, which was approved by voters in 2020 — said he was suspicious of the Petersburg Sullivan’s intentions from the start, and the Times story is no surprise.
Kendall said he doesn’t believe it will influence the lawsuit, which he thinks will be tossed out.
“These really shady allegations do not make a bad lawsuit a good lawsuit,” Kendall said. “That lawsuit’s going to get dismissed because it just doesn’t have any merit.”
“Doesn’t mean I or anyone else likes decoy Dan,” Kendall said, referring to the Petersburg Sullivan. “Doesn’t mean doing what they did was morally correct. They did what toxic national partisans do all the time. They tried to game the system.”
How does ranked choice voting come into play?
Critics of Alaska’s ranked choice voting system say it can encourages “spoiler” candidacies.
Kendall,who is working with the campaign to oppose Ballot Measure 2, which would repeal the state’s open primary and ranked choice voting system, argued that the election system is not responsible for spoiler candidates.
He speculated that Democratic operatives likely would have pushed to get the Petersburg Sullivan on the general election ballot through a third party if the state did not have the open primary election system.
Kendall asserted that ranked choice tabulation ultimately counteracts the effects of a namesake spoiler candidate. Under Alaska’s ranked choice voting system, if no candidate receives more than 50% of first-choice votes, tabulation begins.
The candidate with the fewest first-choice votes is eliminated, and ballots cast for that candidate are redistributed to each voter’s next-ranked candidate still in the race. The process repeats until one candidate receives more than 50% of the votes in the count.
Kendall argued that ranked choice voting can counteract the effects of a namesake candidate. If a voter were to mistakenly rank the Petersburg Sullivan first and Sen. Sullivan second, for example, that vote would transfer to the incumbent senator if the Petersburg Sullivan were eliminated.
“If the voter is confused, they can rank both Dans, and if a voter ranks both Dans, there is zero question, mathematically, that that vote will eventually count for Senator Sullivan,” Kendall said.
In the primary election, the Petersburg Sullivan received most of his votes from more progressive districts.
Kendall said he sees that pattern not as evidence of voter confusion, but as a sign that liberal voters deliberately supported the candidate.
“That didn’t show that it eroded Sen. Sullivan’s support. What it showed was a bunch of progressives kind of foisted this guy on us,” Kendall said.
The post NYT report: Peltola campaign, national Democrats helped get Sen. Sullivan’s namesake challenger on ballot appeared first on Chilkat Valley News.














