Categories
Featured Juneau News Juneau Local Juneau Local Ketchikan Local News Feeds Sitka Local

Alaska’s ferry system could run out of funding this summer due to ‘federal chaos problem’

By: James Brooks, Alaska Beacon

Cars drive aboard the Alaska Marine Highway System ferry Hubbard on June 25, 2023, in Haines. (Photo by James Brooks)

Alaska’s state ferry system is at risk of a partial or total shutdown this summer due to the failure of the federal government to issue a key annual grant.

“Currently right now, we have a shortfall in our budget,” said Dom Pannone, director of program administration and management for the Alaska Department of Transportation and Public Facilities, to members of the Senate Finance Committee during a Monday morning hearing.

Money from the Federal Transit Administration’s rural ferry program pays for almost half of the Alaska Marine Highway System’s operating expenses, but the administration failed to open its annual grant process in fiscal year 2025, which ended Sept. 30. 

The ferry system’s budget runs according to the calendar year. Last spring, the Alaska Legislature and Gov. Mike Dunleavy budgeted $171 million for the 2026 ferry budget. Of that, almost $78 million was supposed to come from the rural ferry program.

Without that money, the system could be forced to tie up its ships in midsummer, at the peak of the state’s annual tourist season.

“Right now, we have a federal chaos problem,” said Sen. Jesse Kiehl, D-Juneau and a member of the Senate Finance Committee.

Ryan Anderson, commissioner of the state DOT, said his agency is “looking at several options” to prevent a shutdown of the ferry system. 

If a federal grant isn’t delivered, DOT would make significant changes to the summer ferry schedule, which is slated for release in May. 

Anderson said the state could “dispose of the Matanuska,” the state’s oldest active ferry, which has been tied up dockside as a “hotel ship” because of maintenance costs. 

The ferry Kennicott, coming out of drydock, or the Columbia, another old mainline ferry, could be tied up as a hotel ship instead of the Matanuska, he said. 

On Monday, neither DOT officials nor state legislators could say why the Federal Transit Administration has failed to make grants available.

“What is going on in Washington, D.C.? That’s always a tough thing to work with,” Anderson said.

U.S. Sen. Lisa Murkowski, R-Alaska, secured almost $1 billion in the 2021 Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act bill for the rural ferry program, which was written in a way to steer much of the money to Alaska. 

By text after Monday’s hearing, Murkowski spokesman Joe Plesha said the Federal Transit Administration told her office it will release the FY26 ferry grants this spring, but did not give a timeline. “We are directly engaged with the FTA and working to advance the release of this grant funding as soon as possible,” Plesha said.

When Murkowski got the ferry language signed into law, it was the first time the federal government had significantly funded operational expenses for Alaska’s ferry system.

“In this particular case, it can actually pay for the operations of those (ferry) vessels,” Anderson said, noting that includes operating costs like crew and fuel. That billion dollars was to be spread across five years, and the program disbursed more than $252 million nationwide in FY22, $170 million in FY23 and $194 million in FY24. 

Alaska received more than five-sixths of the total distribution in that time, something that allowed Gov. Mike Dunleavy to divert state dollars to other parts of Alaska’s annual budget. 

Alaska DOT estimates that about $410 million remains available for the federal government to disburse. 

In each of the three prior grant years, it took between 152 and 199 days from the time the grant application period opened to the time the grant was awarded. 

That timeline means that even if federal transit officials were to open the grant process tomorrow, a decision might not be made before the arrival of the summer ferry schedule in May.

Dunleavy and the Legislature could extend the timeline by changing the ferry system’s budget calendar so that it starts July 1 along with all other state agencies, but if there’s still no federal money, that would just extend operations until January 2027, and then the system would face a $150 million cliff instead of a $78 million one.

Sen. Bert Stedman, R-Sitka, said that finding “backfill” money will be difficult in either case.

“Our budgets are getting tighter and taking away the flexibility the (finance) committee has to backfill some of these holes, and this particular hole could be significant, pushing $80 million,” he said. 

The ferry funding issue could persist even if the federal transit authority resumes paying grants, because its ferry operations program is set to expire this year.

“What happens when that grant money is gone?” asked Sen. Mike Cronk, R-Tok.

“This year, the surface transportation reauthorization is up for renewal,” Anderson said. “This, we understand, is part of that discussion: Will the rural ferry program continue over the next subsequent four years?”

Anderson said that even if Congress renews the program, the current Alaska-favorable rules might be rewritten.

“Other states are very interested in this program as well because they have a lot of similar challenges,” he said. “Nationwide, there’s support for a program such as this. The questions that are out: How will the rules be rewritten, and how competitive will the program be? That will be the challenge.”

Categories
Featured Juneau News Juneau Local Juneau Local Ketchikan Local News Feeds Sitka Local

Alaska again seeks American shipyards to build new oceangoing Tustumena replacement ferry

By: James Brooks, Alaska Beacon

The ferry Tustumena is seen July 20, 2021, in southwestern Alaska. (James Brooks photo)

After more than a decade of planning, design and false starts, the state of Alaska is once more attempting to build its first new mainline ferry in decades.

On Jan. 23, the Alaska Department of Transportation and Public Facilities began advertising for shipyards interested in building a replacement for the Tustumena, which sails between Homer, Kodiak and Unalaska on the longest, most remote state ferry route in the United States.

The new ship must be built in the United States and is expected to cost well over $325 million, based on a prior estimate provided by the state to the federal government and inflation since that 2022 projection. 

The current bid listing states only that the “engineer’s estimate is greater than $100,000,000.” 

The final operational requirements include a 330-foot-long ship with a range of 4,000 nautical miles, and a capacity of 250 passengers and 28 crew plus 58 vehicles. 

A computer-generated mockup of the new Tustumena replacement ferry is seen in an undated image published by the Alaska Department of Transportation and Public Facilities. (DOT image)

The invitation to bid calls for the ship to be complete by the end of January 2029. 

Bids are due by 2 p.m. May 28. 

The federal government is expected to pay for the majority of the project, which has been a state priority since 2013. 

The Tustumena, variously nicknamed “Rusty Tusty” and “Trusty Tusty,” entered service in 1964. 

The years and the rough seas of the North Pacific have taken their toll: In 2012, age-related problems sidelined the ship for months, cutting Kodiak off from the state road system. After an extended stay in drydock, it returned to service, but the experience caused the state to begin planning and designing a replacement.

Plunging oil prices and vanishing state revenue caused legislators and then-Gov. Bill Walker to slash the state’s budget, which put the replacement project on the back burner, and the Tustumena remained in service.

In 2016, part of the ship’s hull cracked badly enough that the Alaska Marine Highway System stopped sailing it in strong storms. 

Subsequent repairs allowed the ship to return to full service, but the state renewed its efforts to replace the Tustumena. In late 2018, just as Walker was leaving office, the state signaled that it would soon begin soliciting bids for a replacement ship.

“The request for proposals will be issued in January 2019 and a ship builder should be selected by June-July 2019,” DOT said at the time.

Gov. Mike Dunleavy, who entered office in December 2018, froze the Tustumena replacement project and similar large-cost state projects as part of a new round of cost-cutting, and in his first years, he significantly cut the budget of the state ferry system, precluding it from going out to bid. By the end of 2021, the Dunleavy administration had relaxed its position on the Tustumena and named it a priority.

In March 2022, the state finally put the project out to bid, but it received no responses by July and canceled the solicitation.

Ferry system officials said they would start a new bidding process in 2023, but that never came to pass. Plans for new bids in 2024 and 2025 also never came about. 

In the meantime, the ship and its propulsion system were repeatedly redesigned, and the Tustumena is now intended to use a diesel-electric drive capable of cruising at 15 knots in moderate, 8-foot seas during the winter, with a maximum speed of 18 knots.