Categories
Uncategorized

The stunning transformation of the Southern Democratic Party, in one lifetime

Mississippi Democratic Gov. Ross Barnett waves a Confederate flag before the start of an Ole Miss-Kentucky football game on Sept. 29, 1962, in Jackson, Miss. AP Photo/Jim Bourdier, File

Two of the biggest surprises of the 2026 election cycle were Democratic U.S. Senate victories in the Deep South. In addition to Annie Andrews’ victory in South Carolina, Scott Colom won a close contest in Mississippi, a place that historian James Cobb called “The Most Southern Place on Earth.”

Colom is not Mississippi’s first Black U.S. senator. Two Black Republicans represented the state during Reconstruction, when state legislatures still selected U.S. senators. But Colom is the state’s first popularly elected Black U.S. senator. He is also the first Democrat that Mississippians have sent to the Senate since 1982.

It is tempting to read this change using a familiar political science term: party realignment. But as political scientists who study political campaigns and Southern politics, we see an equally important transformation in the electorate – the people who can cast votes.

Simply put, the Democratic Party in the South was transformed from a party that defended white supremacy and Black disenfranchisement into one in which Black voters became a central constituency. The Democrats who held Mississippi’s Senate seats for the majority of the 20th century were chosen by an electorate built to exclude Black citizens. Colom was elected by a dramatically different electorate and represents a very different Democratic Party.

To understand the magnitude of the change in Mississippi, it helps to look at the Democrats who came before Colom, what they stood for, and the political power they wielded.

Reconstruction and its end

For a brief period after the Civil War, Black Mississippians exercised real political power. They were a majority of the state’s population and, with the right to vote, helped elect the state Legislature that sent Hiram Revels to the U.S. Senate in 1870 and Blanche Bruce in 1875, both of them Black.

That period did not last. White Democrats regained control of Mississippi government in the 1870s, aided by political violence, intimidation and electoral fraud. In 1890, the state adopted a new constitution that used poll taxes, literacy tests and other restrictions to systematically disfranchise Black voters. Two years after the new constitution took effect, the percentage of Black men registered to vote had fallen to just 5.4 percent.

The result fundamentally changed Mississippi politics. For the next several generations, the Democratic Party dominated a political system in which most Black Mississippians had little meaningful voice. Republican electoral victories were rare. One newspaper in 1963 claimed that the election of Lewis McAllister to the state House was the party’s first win in 43 years. Without a competitive general election, winning the Democratic primary often meant winning office, and the politicians who emerged from a one-party system made possible by Black disenfranchisement became some of the most powerful political figures in the state’s history.

What happened in Mississippi reflected a broader pattern across the South. In 1949, political scientist V.O. Key published his seminal study of the region, “Southern Politics in State and Nation.” Key argued that the solid Democratic South rested on systematic disenfranchisement of Black voters.

The one-party system helped keep Black Southerners out of political power while allowing white Southern politicians to present a unified front against efforts to dismantle segregation and expand Black voting rights, particularly when those efforts came from the federal government. Mississippi was among the clearest examples of that system.

Two men, one sitting and holding a cigar, the other leaning over him with a sheaf of papers in his hand.
Mississippi Senators James O. Eastland, left, and John Stennis, both Democrats, at a Senate subcommittee hearing about hunger on July 11, 1967, in Washington. They angrily denied physicians’ charges that their state was trying to starve African Americans.
AP Photo/John Rous

Segregation and political power

Before Colom, the last Democrat elected to the U.S. Senate from Mississippi was John Stennis in 1982. He first won election in 1947, filling the seat of Theodore Bilbo, who had won reelection in 1946 after a campaign in which he urged white Mississippians to keep Black voters away from the polls. Stennis won a 1947 special election with 52,068 votes in a state of 2.2 million people. He held that seat for 41 years.

Throughout much of his career, Stennis was an ardent segregationist. In 1956, he was one of 101 members of Congress from the South who signed what was called the “Southern Manifesto.” In that statement, these lawmakers denounced the Supreme Court’s decision in Brown v. Board of Education, in which the justices ruled that the “separate but equal” standards of racial segregation were unconstitutional; Stennis and the other signatories pledged resistance to school desegregation.

Later in his Senate career, Stennis was the only Southern Democrat who voted to oppose the creation of a national holiday honoring Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr.

Stennis’ Senate colleague for much of his tenure, Mississippi Democrat James Eastland, was an equally staunch defender of segregation. A cotton planter from the Mississippi Delta, he was appointed to the Senate in 1941 and won the seat outright in 1942. He remained in the Senate until 1978.

The day after the Supreme Court handed down its 1954 decision in Brown v. Board of Education, Eastland was quoted saying, “the South will not abide by nor obey this legislative decision by a political court.”

Recent attention has understandably focused on Stennis, the last Democrat to represent Mississippi in the Senate. When Colom takes office, he will occupy the Senate seat once held by Eastland and Democrat James Vardaman, who said that “if it is necessary every Negro in the state will be lynched; it will be done to maintain white supremacy.”

One-party rule also gave Mississippi’s senators unusual power. With little electoral competition, they could remain in office for decades. In a Senate where seniority mattered, longevity translated into influence.

Eastland, for example, chaired the Senate Judiciary Committee for more than two decades, giving him enormous influence over civil rights legislation. During his chairmanship of the powerful committee, that committee became known as “the graveyard of civil rights legislation,” according to the Senate’s website.

A new Southern coalition

The Voting Rights Act of 1965 helped dismantle the electoral system that had sustained these men in office. Before it, fewer than 10% of Black Mississippians were even registered to vote. Within a few short years, a majority were.

Black voters increasingly aligned with the Democratic Party as its national leaders embraced civil rights, even while many Democratic officeholders in Mississippi continued to defend segregation. That meant Black voters sometimes supported incumbent white segregationists. The party’s voters changed faster than many of its candidates did.

The 1978 election for the seat Colom will hold illustrates how complicated that transition could be. After Eastland retired, Charles Evers, brother of slain civil rights leader Medgar Evers, ran as an independent and drew nearly a quarter of the vote. His candidacy split the traditionally Democratic vote, helping Republican Thad Cochran win with a mere plurality.

By the 21st century, white Mississippians overwhelmingly supported Republican candidates, and Republican dominance had replaced the old Democratic dominance in most statewide elections.

That pattern made Colom’s victory all the more striking. He won with overwhelming support from Black voters while also attracting enough white voters to build a winning statewide coalition.

The contrast with Mississippi’s old Democratic coalition could hardly be sharper. The Democratic Party of Vardaman, Bilbo, Eastland and Stennis maintained its power in part by keeping Black Mississippians away from the ballot box with violence and Jim Crow laws.

When Colom is sworn in, Revels’ old seat will, for the first time, be held by a Black senator directly elected by Mississippi voters.

The Conversation

The authors do not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organization that would benefit from this article, and have disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.

​Politics + Society – The Conversation

Categories
Uncategorized

A Westmoreland County easement shows how landowners can protect farmland without selling it

A conservation easement lets land stay in private hands while limiting what current and future owners can do with it. Jeff Greenberg/Universal Images Group via Getty Images

Scott Tomlinson still owns the 35 acres in Ligonier Township in Westmoreland County, Pennsylvania, that his family has cared for over seven generations. But in July 2026, he sold part of what it means to own them.

For US$139,000, Tomlinson gave the Western Pennsylvania Conservancy the right to enforce restrictions on how the land is used, TribLive reported. The restrictions protect its farmland and woods from future development in perpetuity.

According to the report, the property is about 80% forest, with slopes that drain into a tributary of Loyalhanna Creek. It includes habitat for buffalo nut, a shrub the state lists as a rare species of concern, and farm soils the USDA classifies as “farmland of statewide importance.”

That is how a conservation easement works: The land stays privately owned, but its owners agree to limits on what they can do with it.

Such agreements let today’s landowners make conservation decisions that bind future owners.

In more than two decades of studying private land conservation, I have found that deciding which rights to give up, how to pay for conservation and how to handle future changes can be complicated. My family has also spent roughly two years negotiating an easement on our own family’s ranch in Texas.

Dividing the rights of ownership

Think of land ownership as a bundle of sticks, with each stick representing a different property right. Within the limits of the law, owners can build on the land, farm it, subdivide it and more. An easement separates particular rights from the rest of the bundle.

For example, an access easement gives someone else the right to cross your property. In a conservation easement, the landowner voluntarily gives up the right to use the land in specified ways. A land trust or government agency receives the right to enforce those limits.

A 'For Sale' sign sits in the middle of farm land.
Some landowners use conservation easements to ensure future buyers can’t divide their farms into lots.
Scott Olson/Getty Images News

Imagine someone who owns a 1,000-acre farm that has long been in her family. Development is spreading into the surrounding countryside, and neighboring farms are being divided into smaller properties or subdivisions. She wants her land to stay largely intact. One stick in her bundle is the right to subdivide.

A farmer who grants an easement might agree to limit how many parcels future owners can carve out of the farm while still allowing farming. The farmer could still sell the property or pass it on, but whoever owns it next would also be bound by the restrictions, because the farmer can’t sell rights the farmer no longer owns. Those future owners may have no intention of subdividing. But the farmer who signs the easement can’t know what their children, or someone who buys the farm a century from now, will want to do.

Tomlinson’s worry – that land his family has cared for since the 1870s could be sold off for development once he’s gone – plays out against a broader shift in the county’s farm landscape. According to the USDA Census of Agriculture, Westmoreland County experienced a 10% decline in the total number of farms between 2017 and 2022, dropping from 1,099 to 989 farms, even as total farmland fell only about 4%.

Easements like Tomlinson’s are one way landowners have responded. The Western Pennsylvania Conservancy says it has permanently protected more than 30,000 acres in the Ligonier Valley since the 1970s, more than 12,000 of them through easements.

Negotiating which rights to restrict

Easement terms are negotiated property by property. In my family’s negotiations, we have had to work out what we and future owners can still do with the ranch. We have agreed to limit where future buildings can go, to permanently restrict the use of certain pesticides and to prohibit new roads and stream crossings.

Other easements may allow different agricultural, forestry or construction activities, depending on their terms.

A person surveys land.
Creating a conservation easement means mapping exactly where future buildings, roads and other developments can and can’t go.
Michael Robinson Chavez/Los Angeles Times collection via Getty Images

Reaching agreement can be expensive. Natural Lands, a Pennsylvania land trust, lists typical transaction costs. These include surveys, appraisals, environmental assessments, legal fees, title work and documentation of the property’s existing condition. The cost to negotiate my family’s easement has run well into six figures.

Once an easement is signed, the holder is responsible for monitoring and enforcing it for as long as it lasts. Land trusts commonly ask landowners for stewardship funding to help pay for that future work.

The land trust that holds our easement will work with whoever owns the land after us, not just with us, so choosing the right partner was an important part of our decision.

How conservation is financed

Beyond transaction costs, granting an easement usually lowers a property’s market value.

To see how this works, imagine the hypothetical farm is worth $4 million with its development rights and $2 million once an easement sharply restricts subdividing it. (These figures are for illustration; how much an easement lowers a property’s value varies widely with its location, development potential and the restrictions involved.) Appraisers often value an easement by comparing a property’s value before and after it’s placed on the land. Here, the easement would be worth $2 million: the amount it cuts from the property’s value.

To encourage landowners to grant easements, U.S. tax law allows a charitable deduction for donated easements that meet detailed requirements. Easements can also be sold.

In Tomlinson’s case, private foundation grants paid for the conservancy’s purchase. Government programs offer another route: The U.S. Department of Agriculture helps eligible organizations, such as land trusts and state and local governments, to buy easements on farmland. These payments and tax benefits can help landowners absorb the drop in property value. For the public, buying or subsidizing easements can protect more land per dollar than buying land outright.

Tax benefits and tax abuse

The tax breaks tied to easements have also invited abuse.

The Internal Revenue Service has identified inflated appraisals and improperly large charitable deductions as recurring problems. A 2019 report by the U.S. Government Accountability Office found that some promoters sold investors stakes in partnerships and similar entities that then donated easements at inflated values. When appraisals exaggerate a property’s development potential, investors can claim deductions based on those inflated values.

A large, official-looking building in the middle of a busy street.
Conservation easements are recorded with the property’s deed. In Westmoreland County, that happens at the courthouse in Greensburg.
Bob Weston/iStock via Getty Images Plus

Congress later restricted deductions for certain conservation contributions by partnerships and corporations. Courts have also disallowed deductions and imposed penalties in abusive transactions.

What it means to protect land forever

To qualify for the federal charitable deduction, a donated easement must protect the land permanently.

Property scholar Gerald Korngold of New York Law School has argued that the permanence that makes easements attractive also makes them hard to adjust and that changing ecological conditions and competing community needs can create reasons to revisit restrictions.

In one case Korngold describes, a conservation easement in Vermont blocked the federal government from adding the land to a national wildlife refuge – a move every party supported – because federal rules require clear title.

I have taught property law for decades and have written about the challenges of private land conservation for much of that time. These experiences taught me that an easement has to address two things: what to protect and what happens if circumstances change.

Negotiating one for my family’s ranch made that, and the bundle of sticks metaphor, real for me. We had to write language setting the dimensions of the particular sticks my grandchildren will live with, under conditions none of us can predict.

Done properly, a conservation easement leaves room for land use to adapt without undermining its conservation goals. It lets landowners like Tomlinson’s family and mine protect land while keeping it in private hands.

Read more of our stories about Pittsburgh and Pennsylvania.

The Conversation

Andrew P. Morriss is affiliated with Property and Environment Research Center (PERC).

​Politics + Society – The Conversation

Categories
Uncategorized

WPTavern: #242 – Mark Westguard on How WordPress Adapts to Rapid Change: the Dot-Com Bubble to AI Hysteria

Transcript

[00:00:19] Nathan Wrigley: Welcome to the Jukebox Podcast from WP Tavern. My name is Nathan Wrigley.

Jukebox is a podcast which is dedicated to all things WordPress. The people, the events, the plugins, the blocks, the themes, and in this case, how WordPress adapts to rapid change the .com bubble to AI hysteria.

If you’d like to subscribe to the podcast, you can do that by searching for WP Tavern in your podcast player of choice, or by going to wptavern.com/feed/podcast, and you can copy that URL into most podcast players.

If you have a topic that you’d like us to feature on the podcast, I’m keen to hear from you and hopefully get you, or your idea, featured on the show. Head to wptavern.com/contact/jukebox, and use the form there.

So on the podcast today we have Mark Westguard. Mark has been building websites for over 30 years, starting out in the early days of the web with his agency, Absolute Internet in the UK, before moving to the US and transitioning into product development. He now runs WS Form, a form plugin for WordPress.

During this episode, we get into the evolution of the internet and WordPress through major technological inflexion points. Most recently, the rise of AI. Mark draws comparisons between the AI era and the frenzy of the .com boom, sharing how rapid influxes of investments and hype, can reshape the entire landscape, often faster than the underlying technology can deliver sustainable results.

The conversation focused not just on the opportunities AI brings to developers and end users, such as dramatically lowering the barrier to entry for building websites or plugins, but also the risks and challenges.

We chat about the overwhelming pace of new product creation, and how the real difficulty today isn’t necessarily building a plugin, but successfully marketing, supporting and sustaining it in a crowded ecosystem.

Towards the end, we talk about the potential saturation of plugin marketplaces and what this means for the future of WordPress businesses, especially as AI continues to accelerate product development.

Mark says that he’s embracing AI in his own workflow, but has some nostalgia for the days when coding was a hands-on craft.

Several other points were raised, including the ongoing demand for trusted, supported, software among non-developers, the looming spectre of AI driven security vulnerabilities, and whether traditional CMS platforms like WordPress might see a renaissance if AI hype collapses.

If you’re curious about how AI is shaping, and challenging, the future of WordPress development and product businesses, this episode is for you.

If you’re interested in finding out more, you can find all of the links in the show notes by heading to wptavern.com/podcast, where you’ll find all the other episodes as well.

And so without further delay, I bring you Mark Westguard.

I am joined on the podcast by Mark Westguard. Hello, Mark.

[00:03:34] Mark Westguard: Hello Nathan, how are you?

[00:03:35] Nathan Wrigley: Yeah, good. We’re going to have a little bit of a chat today about the landscape of WordPress in the era of AI. Let’s explore and see where we go.

So Mark, before we begin, bio time, basically, would you give us your little bio? Tell us what you do in the WordPress space.

[00:03:50] Mark Westguard: In the WordPress space, currently I’m running, WS Form, which is an online form plugin for WordPress.

And I’ve been in the web game far too long. People can’t see our grey hairs, but I’ve been building websites for, oh, I want to say about 30 odd years now.

Yeah, I’ve gone through everything from Netscape Navigator through to where we are now with AI. So, have been building websites for many many companies, for many many years.

So I had a agency in the UK called Absolute Internet back in the day, back in 1996. And then moved to the States in 2005 and carried on with that, and then got into product about, I want to say eight years ago now. And have been enjoying it, but still dabbling in the agency side of things as well.

[00:04:34] Nathan Wrigley: Okay, so you’ve had a long and storied history. Has there ever been a moment where it’s felt like so much was in flux, in your past? Because, I think anybody really listening to this would have some intuition that AI is a moment of great inflexion point. Maybe this is par for the course though, over a 30 year period in the internet. Has there been anything which has disrupted things or changed things as rapidly as this?

[00:04:56] Mark Westguard: I think, for me it was strange because the internet was there when I started university, but definitely was a big game changer for how we accessed information and searched for information.

The next big thing for me was really the .com bubble, and that going bang quite tremendously, which pulled my first agency into the ground. I mean, we went from 40 odd staff to four people in a day. So that was certainly a big flux in the internet industry that hit me.

Once that recovered, it’s been fairly plain sailing, hasn’t it? There’s been a lot of gentle progression in the internet game. We’ve seen CSS 2, CSS 3. We’ve seen HTML get a little bit better here and there, standards have improved. But nothing like AI. I mean, I remember the first time I typed a question into a bot and got a response back and I was like, okay, this is going to change things.

So yeah, we’re definitely in a big evolution here and one that I think is way more rapid than internet hitting us as well.

[00:05:58] Nathan Wrigley: I think the bit that makes it so profound is the fact that we’ve given over so much of ourselves to the internet. So during the .com boom, there were, I don’t know, how many desktop computers in the UK. I imagine there’s significantly more than there were then than there are now. You know, you had to go and find a computer, sit at a computer, switch the computer on, use things like dial up modems to get access.

[00:06:22] Mark Westguard: Yeah.

[00:06:23] Nathan Wrigley: And all of that kind of stuff, many obstacles. And now everything is in your pocket. So we do commerce in our pocket. We communicate from our, the device in our pocket. In other words, everything is wedded to the internet.

So the idea of things changing rapidly because we’ve become so accustomed to the internet being kind of like a utility. The rapid change is more profound, even if the change itself might not be so rapid.

Can I actually go back to the .com boom and bust bit? Because I bet a significant proportion of the people listening to this won’t even know what that was. Do you want to describe it, and how it crept up on you and overnight just decimated probably billions of dollars from stock markets?

[00:07:05] Mark Westguard: Yeah, it was around about, I want to say 2000, right when it hit. And when we first started as an agency, I was building websites using university computers. I didn’t own a computer. This is what you were talking about. Not everybody could have afford that technology back then.

But we were building websites for the most bizarre stuff. We had people coming in saying, I want to sell curry online. And I want to, anything and everything that they could come up with as with an idea, they were getting funding for.

And we were dealing with small one man bands, but we’re also dealing with big companies that had huge investment, that was pumped into these internet ideas. And it’s kind of similar to what’s happening with AI right now.

There’s an immense amount of money being invested into it. And the internet went from a handful of university websites, to everybody doing all manner of things online. The investment just got over the top. And then at some point somebody went, you know what, these investments have no ROI on them. There’s huge amounts of money being poured into this. And, basically the stock market crashed as a result of it.

And we had companies literally within a week saying, we are no longer going to be continuing our management contracts with you. Or we don’t want to build this website with you anymore. We were building $2 – 300,000 websites for the likes of Safeway and Sony and KPMG and all kinds of stuff. And it just stopped overnight. And it caused a lot of agencies to fall over, just completely fail, within a matter of months.

[00:08:37] Nathan Wrigley: I remember seeing an ad, I was on Kensington High Street in London. I used to work on Kensington High Street, and I remember seeing an ad on a bus stop. So it was a prime bit of real estate in the UK, probably one of the more expensive places that you could put an ad. And it was for an internet product. And the product was that they would come to your workplace, take your shirt, iron it, and bring it back to you. And I remember looking at ad and thinking, is that really what they’re selling? Genuinely? Like, is there a market for that? And obviously, within a month the .com bubble had burst.

But it was on that level, wasn’t it? It was the most peculiar ideas that people could come up with. And maybe some of them would’ve swum now. But back then, everything was sort of sinking. But also nobody had a mechanism to pay for it. We didn’t have the sort of access to credit and credit cards and Stripe and all of those payment gateways and all of that.

It was just, we were falling over ourselves to put ideas out there. Nobody seemed to have the capacity to say, no, look objectively, that’s a silly idea. That there’s no business there. It was more, let’s try it.

And then eventually a bit like happened with the Dutch and the tulips way back. Somebody woke up and said, hang on, there’s no money being generated by these things. Then presumably the bankers all took one look at each other and went, oh, what have we done.

[00:10:04] Mark Westguard: Yeah. And there were a lot of big, big ideas out there that caused a lot of that. I had one guy that came in and I won’t mention the project name, to save the guy’s grace. But he had come up with an idea to do an online training platform for children. And this guy we found out afterwards had maxed out his credit cards, had remortgaged his house, had got divorced from his wife, and a tiny part of the reason for the collapse around 2000. But it was that kind of thing that was happening all over the place.

[00:10:35] Nathan Wrigley: Yeah.

[00:10:36] Mark Westguard: We are seeing a similar thing happening now with AI. There’s a huge amount of investment going into it. Now I’m in no way an expert in the financial world and of investment in AI platforms and stuff, but hopefully we don’t see as big a bang as we did back then.

[00:10:50] Nathan Wrigley: It felt, at the time, it felt really normal until it suddenly didn’t. Until I saw that ad for that shirt ironing business, I genuinely I just thought, oh, that’s a good idea. Oh, that’s interesting. Look what they’re doing. Look what you can do now. Ads over and over again.

But then as soon as it starts to unravel, you begin to get the intuition. Wow, that really was hysteria. We were all caught up in this hysteria. Whether or not you are a financial expert, it must be obvious to everybody that we are caught up in some kind of AI hysteria at the moment.

Now, it may be that 80% of all of the business ideas based around AI will succeed. Maybe it’ll be that 80% of them will fail. But have you got any intuitions that point to it being over egged, hysteria? Are there any things that you’ve seen out in the real world where you’ve thought, boy, that really does feel like a moment where we ought to be thinking about whether we’re caught up in mass hysteria here?

[00:11:48] Mark Westguard: I think AI for me is like the next logical progression. We’re talking about coding here, right? AI is used for lots of different things, but in terms of coding, it’s like the next logical transition in terms of making coding accessible.

So if I think back to when I was in college and I was writing machine code for chips, literally like bite by bite, that was quite complicated. And then came along programming languages where we could not have to worry about the machine coding. And then we’ve got things like, for example Basic on a computer, which meant you didn’t have to worry about some of the more underlying code underneath that.

And then came the internet with HTML. And then we had page builders. Now I’ve got AI where we don’t even have to think about writing a line of code. You can literally just ask it what you want, and hopefully you’ll get out of it what you want. At every stage it has made working with a computer, and making a computer do something more accessible to more people.

So now my father can just go online and say, hey, build me this website. I want a green background. I want this font, I want it to say this. Write me a paragraph about such and such, and they can pretty much whip something up in an afternoon. A year ago, two years ago, that was him having to learn how to code to do that, or would have to use a drag and drop page editor to do that. So it really has opened up the ability to develop software and websites to a lot more people.

The thing that I’m seeing is there’s an awful lot of ideas being developed. People are coming up with ideas. Some people not actually thinking about, is this a project that’s got legs? Do people need this? There’s a lot of repetition going on. There’s a lot of things being built where really, even if you build a website solution or a piece of software, you’ve still got to market that. You’ve still got to support it. You’ve still got to get it out to the masses.

And AI’s not quite there with that yet. I can’t just say, right I’ve built this product, go and market it for me. It’s still going to need some feet on the ground to actually go out there and sell a product.

When I got into software and I developed WS Form, building the actual plugin was a lot easier than actually getting out there and getting people interested in it, and telling people about why it’s a good product. That’s what took the time.

[00:13:57] Nathan Wrigley: That’s a curious insight. So we are in a moment now where almost anybody who’s got the capacity to type on a computer can build anything. And I’m seeing that over the internet at the moment. You said multiple things.

So there’s this person that I follow online, I won’t mention their name. They’re not in the WordPress space at all. And if you follow their trajectory, about a year ago, they clearly got the intuition that they could build an app. And so they did for the Mac, and it was really great. It was really good little app and it served its purpose. It was quite a small thing.

Now, a year later, I would think it’s probably fair to say they’ve probably got about 15 apps. And there was some moment, and I don’t know when it was, probably about the 10th one in, I suddenly thought, how does this person maintain this? Is this just a case of just, okay, let’s build another and another and just keep going through that process. Selling, selling more, selling, more selling. But at what point do the people buying that app get the support that they need and the bug fixes that they need? And that I think is maybe a moment that we haven’t yet faced.

[00:15:02] Mark Westguard: Yeah.

[00:15:02] Nathan Wrigley: The marketing bit. You’ve built a plugin with AI for WordPress, but you don’t have the capacity to market it. So you build another one, and you build another one, and you build another one. But the few people that bought it, they’re going to expect updates and what have you. What I’m basically trying to do is agree with what you said. The wider bit is the harder bit. The selling it, not just building it, and then making sure that those people come back for more later.

[00:15:25] Mark Westguard: Yeah, I think that’s one part that a lot of people are missing. I’m seeing a lot of people saying, hey, I built this and I’m making X million per month. I don’t believe a lot of those posts that you see, with these get rich. If that was the case, everyone would be doing it.

But, I love AI. It’s made my ability to bug test and launch new features so much quicker, and so much more efficient. I just worry that there are so many people jumping into wanting to build businesses with it without thinking about all the other stuff that you’ve got to do to make that business a success.

And that’s kind of what I saw back in the two thousands. I saw a lot of people just coming up with ideas, running with it. They were starters but they weren’t finishers. And the actual marketing of that idea, and getting it supported and everything else was the they fell on.

Yeah, it’s, an interesting time and it’s really hard to keep up with it all because it’s moving so quickly. That’s the bit that for me is a challenge, is just keeping up with the best thing to do. And there are so many people online, on social media that are trying to tell you the best way of doing it. Everyone’s got their own, way of doing it. I’ve had to switch a lot of it off. It’s overwhelming.

[00:16:29] Nathan Wrigley: Okay, so that’s a curious insight. And it was where I was going to go next. I genuinely don’t know what our capacity is to consume this. I don’t know where all the people are going to come from to buy all these things. In order for us to to buy all these things, we must all be earning to pay for all these things. And in order to earn, we all need to be selling our own things or doing some kind of lucrative work somewhere. You know to shell out for these things.

That’s the bit that I’m concerned about. I don’t see where all of these products are going to get revenue from. In the WordPress space, let’s cast our minds back three years. Competition was tough already. You know, you’re in a fairly competitive landscape, WordPress forms, there’s several solutions for that. So that’s already competitive.

Now if you flood the zone with 10 more, 15 more, a hundred more, that means it’s much more difficult for everybody to achieve the sort of the weight that they need to have to make that profitable.

It’s very hard to encapsulate what I’m trying to say, but it basically boils down to what is our capacity to attend to all of this stuff. And I was thinking this morning, coincidentally before you and I joined the call, I was thinking before computers came along, I know life wasn’t as rich and wasn’t as varied, but it was a heck of a lot less noisy. And we really do allow a lot of noise to get into our lives. And it feels like AI, WordPress, it’s very noisy at the moment. And I don’t think we’ve yet crossed that Rubicon. The noise, it’s become obvious to us how disruptive that noise was.

[00:18:07] Mark Westguard: Yeah.

[00:18:08] Nathan Wrigley: I think we’re still, in many cases, plugin vendors and theme vendors and things are still relying on previous year’s subscription to renew, but it’s the next year that I worry about and the year after that. And I don’t know if you’ve got any wisdom there.

[00:18:23] Mark Westguard: It’s an interesting time. I think there’s a lot of experimenting going on that is being portrayed as the way to do things. There’s a lot of people, I guess there’s a lot of people panicking. There’s even a lot of people in the WordPress world that have gone from WordPress to now saying, I’m not doing WordPress anymore, and they’re now a hundred percent AI. And, are they actually producing things that are making them a living? Other than maybe, some of these online content producers. Are there solid products that are coming out of AI?

If you just look at the plugin repo, the number of plugin submissions has gone through the roof because so many people can now just produce utility plugins so quickly and easily. There are still only a handful of people out there actually producing proper products, that are selling as plugins for WordPress, sizable plugins that are really expensive to build with AI. I’m fortunate that I didn’t have a suite of small utility plugins. I had quite a large form engine that I intentionally built to be quite complicated, and that’s kept me afloat.

[00:19:23] Nathan Wrigley: Oh, I see. You’ve got like a walled garden around your product a bit because of its complexity, but also it’s not a utility in the sense that you toggle something on and then something happens on your website. I don’t know, SMTP plugin or something like that. It just this one thing and it does it, and that’s all it does.

Yours is much more broad, deep, there’s a learning curve, but also it performs an essential function on the website. If that was to go away, your forms disappear from your website, that’s catastrophic potentially. So you’ve created a bit of a moat around yourself because of that.

[00:19:57] Mark Westguard: Yeah, I don’t think I created it. I just think that happened. Almost the marketing of the product has changed. I used to be pushing, hey, no code forms just drag and drop. Some people don’t even use the UI anymore. They literally are just using AI to talk to it, because it has the MCP server on it. So it has become more of an engine than a user interface for building a form.

And, we were going to talk briefly about block themes and stuff, on this call and I had recently transitioned my theme on my website from a classic theme to a block theme. And the amount of work that went into that was a lot more than I thought it was going to be with AI. And that’s because I think AI still is filling in the holes a lot.

So, the more vague your prompt is, the more AI’s got to do to fit in the gap. So if I just say to it, build me a website, it’ll build you a website, but you are going to have, umpteen different things that it has assumed that you want along the way.

When I was building my block theme, using AI, there was a lot of prompting I had to do to get it to look the way I wanted it to look. And it took a lot more, I forget how many prompts it was now. It was several hundred prompts in the end to get it where I wanted it to be.

Glad I did it. And I did it a lot quicker than I would’ve done had I hand coded it for sure. And it did things that I am not very good at doing, like writing a block from scratch, that’s still something that I struggle with, and it was really helpful to be able to do that with AI.

You see this in social media, people saying, oh, that guy’s built a website and it looks like it was built from AI. And that’s basically AI fitting in the gaps with what it’s been taught that people want. Certain fonts, certain things like that. So you can definitely use it to, I’ve completely digressed here but, you can definitely build it to build things quicker, but it still takes time to prompt it properly.

And also with someone with programming knowledge, I’m still steering it in certain directions to make it work the way I want, and to make it work efficiently. I’ll still look at code that AI generates and be like, what are you doing?

[00:21:51] Nathan Wrigley: I was just going to interrupt there and say, I guess the curious bit about this is that in in every epoch until now, the frailty of the human being, our capacity to forget things, the fact that we can only allocate a certain amount of our brain to a given task. We require sleep and all of these kind of ordinary things. And we get unwell, we’re not always as efficient one day as we are the next, because we went out the night before, and those kind of things.

I suppose that is also a part of the jigsaw puzzle, which has me concerned, is that the state of AI. Let’s assume a trajectory which is the same as the last five years. Let’s assume that in the next five years the trajectory’s going to be the same. Of course it may not turn out that way, but let’s assume that it does. The worst is now. The worst that an AI can do is today, and tomorrow it will be better, and the day after that, it will be better. And it will never be worse.

And so those little wrinkles that you described, you have to prompt it 200 times to get yourself a website. You’ve got to assume that the combined kind of Borg-like, that’s a Star Trek analogy, kind of Borg-like nature of AI, is that in a year’s time, it’ll be a hundred prompts. The year after that, or six months after that, it’ll be down to 50, and then 20, and then 10. And you get what I’m saying.

You know, it just get’s exponentially better. It never gets worse. That, I think, is the bit that me the most. Is that because it’s beguiling and because as technologists we love shiny stuff, that we don’t see this giant problem building behind our backs. That if we’re constantly beguiled by the shiny, and we give everything over to the AI, maybe there’ll come a point where we look and we suddenly realise, oh, it’s now superior than I am in every single regard in terms of website building. So who’s going to use my services anymore?

[00:23:42] Mark Westguard: Yeah.

[00:23:43] Nathan Wrigley: And I find this a curious thing in the WordPress space, because a lot of people seem to be hyping AI to the exclusion of their future selves.

[00:23:54] Mark Westguard: Yeah. Yep.

[00:23:55] Nathan Wrigley: But they can’t, it’s irresistible. You have to do it, because if you don’t, your competitor will. And so you know, the arms race argument comes out and on we go. And it’s a curious thing that we’re in this moment.

[00:24:08] Mark Westguard: It’s a funny time for sure. It’s the buzzword. It’s what everybody’s focusing on right now. I’m doing it. I am using it as much as I can. It’ll be silly for me not to do that. I embrace it.

You know, I was working with James LePage and his team at Automattic when they were developing all of the different AI building blocks. And he very kindly kept me ahead of what was going on there.

And I’m very thankful for that because it’s one of the things that’s made my product ahead of some of the competition. And I’ve got people now recommending WS Form because of the AI capabilities that it has.

But it’s a completely different way of thinking and working from what I was used to. For me to add a new feature meant adding a new UI interface for it, and writing all of that from scratch. And we were talking before this call that I would probably spend a day or two implementing a new feature and working it out. And I used to love that. That used to be good for my brain.

And I was thinking the other day, I am getting to the point where I’m not thinking anymore. Because I, it just, it’s doing the thinking part of it for me. But my experience in building just that block theme from my website taught me that, much like going to an agency and telling it what logo you have and what colours you have and how you want things to look and how you want things spaced out. All of that initial discovery period still needs to be done with AI in order to get it to do what you want.

Now, like you say, it’s going to be able to do that more and more efficiently. You see that with like Claude design where you can set up a, I forget what they call it now, but you kind of build like a design set.

[00:25:39] Nathan Wrigley: Yeah, like a brand kit kind of thing?

[00:25:40] Mark Westguard: Yeah. Where you give it your logo and your styling and everything else. And you can give it, even the current web address of your site and it’ll feed that in. And then it can then use that to build new elements.

So, there’s still a lot of prompted stuff that goes on. I think there’s a little bit of a myth that you can literally one prompt AI for a lot of things, and get some output from it.

One of the interesting things for me is I went to an AI event once, and I met a guy who was, I think he was ex OpenAI. And he said to me and this may or may not be true, but the fundamental software powering everything in AI, the concept behind it has kind of hit a threshold. And what we are now doing is tweaking that and making that work better. We’re tuning it, fine tuning it.

And that’s where we see an improvement in AI and obviously in processor speed and everything else that’s going on. So it’s interesting that kind of the fundamentals of AI are really at a maximum, in terms of what it can do. But it’s really human tweaking it and training it that’s making it work an awful lot better. And I think that’s where a lot of the improvements are going to come from.

[00:26:38] Nathan Wrigley: You mentioned a little bit ago that you’ve really not required to write code anymore in order to improve your plugin. You can get AI in the loop there and tweak it and iterate on it that way. Do you miss that though?

[00:26:51] Mark Westguard: Yeah, I really do.

[00:26:53] Nathan Wrigley: Is there a bit of you that you could close the box on AI and just rewind the clock and go back to the way it was? Because presumably it wasn’t all roses and unicorns over there. It was hard work and probably kept you awake at night and you’re banging your head against the desks, or how do I do this? Is there some kind of halcyon days thinking there, you know, ah it was better before AI. Would you parcel it up and send AI packing if you could, or are you more happy with it.

[00:27:18] Mark Westguard: It’s a love hate relationship for sure. Love hate relationship. I think, much like a carpenter loves doing woodwork. I used to love coding, call me a nerd. But that was my trade. That’s what I did. And I used to love working things out. And that working out is what kept my brain ticking over.

Now if I have something I need to do, I can get AI to build it. Now, I will absolutely, and that’s hopefully where the quality of my product comes is, I’ll go and check what it’s written. I won’t just implement it and launch it. I will always check what it’s done, and nine times outta 10 I’ll find better ways of doing it. Just because of the way that it’s implemented it. It may not understand that I’ve got a method in my code somewhere that already does that. So I don’t want it to recode it.

But the more and more I use it, the more it seems to understand my code base, and the way it works. And it’s getting better and better. It is like having an assistant in the office that can just deal with the coding for me now. But I do miss it. I really do. Sometimes I’ll just get my hands dirty and do a bit of coding for the old days, but I sit there thinking I could have just prompted AI and it would’ve done it in five seconds. So it’s yeah, it’s weird.

[00:28:22] Nathan Wrigley: It’s almost like a hobby. You take time off and pursue a hobby of coding as opposed to the business of coding, which is kind of curious.

[00:28:28] Mark Westguard: Yeah. And I do miss that. Yeah. And it was a hobby. You would get questioned sometimes, what’s your hobby? And I’d think, oh, is it? What do I? Do I write swimming or, or eating at a restaurant? I’m like, no, I actually, yeah, I used to love coding. My hobby was my job, and I was very lucky in that regard that I was doing what I enjoy doing as a career. So that, yeah, part of that’s missing now. And I do miss it.

But at the same time, I love technology and I love seeing new things come to fruition. And I’ve loved learning about and taking advantage of AI. And there’s been things in my product that people probably aren’t even aware that are little bugs that have just been niggling at me that I’ve never got round to fixing.

[00:29:08] Nathan Wrigley: And now you can.

[00:29:08] Mark Westguard: I just spend a day and I’m just like, you know what? Fix that little pixel that’s out that’s been bugging me all these years, and it’ll work it out for me.

[00:29:16] Nathan Wrigley: I am so torn on this subject because I, like anybody that enjoys technology, I really love when I see a new thing. Whether that’s a piece of hardware or software or the capacity of somebody to do something new, raising the standard of people to do a thing. So on that side of it, it’s all, like I said, unicorns and rainbows. It’s brilliant.

But there is a bit of me, which I think growing in size, which is very concerned. And there are so many underpinnings to that. The people growing up now presumably will not be able to go through the process of learning that you went through. Because what would be the point in spending all those hours learning to do all of the things that you had to do and bang your head against the desk. And so that worries me.

It worries me that if we flood the landscape, our capacity to engage with that is going to go away. Like, how many Mac apps can we have and how many WordPress plugins can we have? At what point does that marketplace become so saturated that nobody can make a living from that anymore? I don’t know if that’ll turn out to be the case. But there’s just this niggling thing that there’s maybe going to be some correction.

And I think the bit, which seems to be raising its head at the moment is AI’s capacity to go out and cause mischief in terms of security vulnerabilities and hacking and things like that. And I do wonder if that will be the thing which enables governments, for example, or regulatory authorities and things like that, to say, wait, the brakes need to go on now.

[00:30:54] Mark Westguard: Yeah.

[00:30:55] Nathan Wrigley: We need to figure out how was this allowed to happen? How is it that our banking systems collapsed? Or how is it that the fridges all got switched up to 50 degrees centigrade?

[00:31:04] Mark Westguard: Which they did.

[00:31:04] Nathan Wrigley: Which they did. How did we allow this to happen? But at the moment, we’re in that kind of free market phase of let it all go wild. But I’m not sure that’s going to be possible forever.

[00:31:16] Mark Westguard: I think it’s going wild on the software side. It’s also going wild just on the infrastructure side right now. The amount of money that’s being pumped into building these server farms and everything else, it’s just off the charts crazy.

Who knows how much this stuff actually costs to run. I feel like we’re in an age where we’re getting quite a good deal on this stuff at the moment. Because we’re in the initial Google phase where Google didn’t have Google ads. It was literally just a search engine and losing huge amounts of money.

It was only when they monetized it that they started to make some kind of profit, and even that took them a long long time. And we are there with these AI farms. They’re huge buildings, massive amounts of investment. And we are paying $20 a month to utilise, effectively, we’ve each got a super computer from a decade or so ago on our desk now.

[00:32:02] Nathan Wrigley: Yeah you’ve got God-like capabilities for a few dollars a month.

[00:32:05] Mark Westguard: I know. Yeah.

[00:32:06] Nathan Wrigley: It’s genuinely insane. Okay. So that’s an interesting point as well. I wonder, so two things here.

The first one is, I wonder if a potential course correction there. The economic model turns out to be unsustainable. And it either collapses or it slowly sort of changes and the fees go up and the capacity to use it goes down. So there’s that.

But also, I wonder if more local AI systems where you download something onto your computer and utilise it there. As opposed to needing the big thing out in the, server farm, the data centre, nobody wants them near their backyard. It certainly seems like that in the UK and it sounds like North America is the same.

The follow on from that is then I wonder if there will be some kind of resurgence for older technology like WordPress. Okay, that was all a bit of fun. We all had a great time playing with the AI, but now that it’s gone in the way that we got familiar with, let’s just revive all the things that we knew used to work. Like our old trusty CMS, WordPress.

I think that’s that’s a possibility, right? The curiosity will dwindle in AI and it will return. Certainly that seems to be the kind of pivot that a lot of people in the WordPress space are hoping for. You know, that AI won’t be able to update your website in the way that clients wish. Use a trusty CMS. AI is going to collapse. Don’t worry, you’ve got the old technology like WordPress, that CMS in your back pocket.

I don’t know if any of those will turn out to be the truth, but certainly an interesting piece to put on the chessboard.

[00:33:37] Mark Westguard: Yeah. And I talk to a lot of plugin developers. Obviously, I’ve got a big community of friends that build plugins and we’re all seeing a decline in new customers. And I think part of that is economy. I think part of that is AI. I think that when I think about it and I look at who I’m looking at like on social media, a lot of those people are very good developers. They’re people that are pretty high up on the WordPress ladder, and developed tools and have developed software themselves.

But there’s still a massive user base in WordPress of people that just want to buy a piece of software that’s tried and tested and works. And don’t want to have to work out how to do that with AI. And go through that because, you could, get AI and say, okay, build me a plugin. And then they’re like, okay well, how do I deploy that? How do I test it? How do I do the security on it? Anyway, there’s a lot that goes into it.

And building stuff from scratch, sometimes, isn’t the best way of doing things. For a lot of people that are developers and know how it all works, it’s great. I can build utility plugins day in, day out now. I don’t even build custom field stuff. I don’t even use a custom field plugin now because I can do that with AI for my own theme. I don’t need it.

If I build a site for a customer, then a lot of the custom stuff I am just writing myself because it’s a few lines of code and AI can do that for me. But there’s still people that aren’t developers. They’re not coders and they just want to be able to buy a bit of software for 50 bucks or whatever, install it, and then it does its job.

[00:35:00] Nathan Wrigley: So that’s a curious thing. And I would fit into that camp. If you took me into any industry apart from web development, WordPress, and you asked me to be confident with, okay, you’ve got the AI thing over here, or you’ve got the $50 thing over there, which somebody else is going to maintain, and you can kind of phone them up if the products itself wouldn’t work.

Genuinely I’m going to pay for the $50 thing, or the a hundred dollars thing. I would never rely on AI. And think about WordPress websites. The amount of clients that I had over the years, who wouldn’t even dare to click the save button, because they were terrified that what they were about to do might in some way just destroy the website, you know, and and they would constantly seek reassurance. Are you sure that I can click save? Yeah. Yeah. click save. It’s absolutely fine. Those people are not going away anywhere.

Although we may become slightly more forgiving of AI, and slightly more trustworthy of it. I think most people in the world, most people in the world, let’s say this sentence again, have never touched an AI.

[00:35:57] Mark Westguard: Yeah.

[00:35:58] Nathan Wrigley: They don’t even know how to interact with it. They wouldn’t know what to do with it if you put it in front of them.

We’re that tiny cabal of people who because we’re on the computers already every day AI and code kind of fit hand in glove, we assume that the rest of the world is happy with this stuff and honestly they’re probably not.

[00:36:16] Mark Westguard: Yeah, and the WordPress world is not a hundred percent developers using it. It’s, there’s a lot of just regular end users that want to build a website, or have in the past maybe installed a classic theme or a block theme, or gone to a developer to build themselves the site. But they’re still using blocks of software to this day.

I mean, every customer that I’ve got is built on WordPress. They’re happy with it, they’re still using it. I work with some very large companies and they’re still using WordPress as the foundation. And we take advantage of AI to be able to roll things out quicker, which is great.

But if I wanted to, if there’s a piece of software that’s quite complicated and that the website relies on it, I won’t necessarily build that with AI. I’ll use an off, piece of off the shelf software that is tried and tested and works, and has the support there for it. I do a lot of stuff with Salesforce, for example, and that could be quite complicated. And, it would take a while to get some of the stuff that we’ve built still done with AI. And there’s pieces of software that we are running that we just pay, 50 bucks a month for and it works, it does the job.

[00:37:14] Nathan Wrigley: I think it’ll be a really interesting moment in the next couple of years seeing where we get with this. Not only whether AI can financially support itself, but whether or not there are outcomes which AI presents to the world that are not aligned to our best interests. Hacking scandals, those kind of things. Whether or not we turn our backs on it and say, put it back. We did enough with AI, we had an experiment with it, and it went slightly pear shaped.

[00:37:37] Mark Westguard: It was great for cat videos.

[00:37:38] Nathan Wrigley: It was brilliant for making videos of yourself, or your politician of choice, doing something that they actually didn’t do. Those kind of things. It was a lot of fun. I mean it’s so beguiling, but who knows where we’ll get to in the year 2027, 2028.

[00:37:55] Mark Westguard: It’s an interesting time.

[00:37:57] Nathan Wrigley: Let’s hope we’re all here to. Yeah, that’s right. We hope we’re all here to experience it. Let’s knock it on the head there. Mark Westguard. Where can we find you online?

[00:38:04] Mark Westguard: wsform.com. Just go on there. You can find information about the product. You can find me on, I’m on Twitter, Facebook all over the place. If you search for Mark Westguard, I’m going to come up. There aren’t many Mark Westguards in the world, so.

[00:38:17] Nathan Wrigley: Perfect. Alright, thank you for chatting to me today. I hope that we both get through to 2027. Take care Mark.

[00:38:23] Mark Westguard: Take care. Bye.

On the podcast today we have Mark Westguard.

Mark has been building websites for over 30 years, starting out in the early days of the web with his agency Absolute Internet in the UK, before moving to the US and transitioning into product development. He now runs WS Form, a form plugin for WordPress.

During this episode we get into the evolution of the internet and WordPress through major technological inflection points, most recently, the rise of AI. Mark draws comparisons between the AI era and the frenzy of the dot-com boom, sharing how rapid influxes of investment and hype can reshape the entire landscape, often faster than the underlying technology can deliver sustainable results.

The conversation focused not just on the opportunities AI brings to developers and end-users, such as dramatically lowering the barrier to entry for building websites or plugins, but also the risks and challenges. We chat about the overwhelming pace of new product creation, and how the real difficulty today isn’t necessarily building a plugin, but successfully marketing, supporting, and sustaining it in a crowded ecosystem.

Towards the end we talk about the potential saturation of plugin marketplaces and what this means for the future of WordPress businesses, especially as AI continues to accelerate product development. Mark says that he’s embracing AI in his own workflow, but has some nostalgia for the days when coding was a hands-on craft.

Several other points were raised, including the ongoing demand for trusted, supported software among non-developers, the looming spectre of AI-driven security vulnerabilities, and whether traditional CMS platforms like WordPress might see a renaissance if AI hype collapses.

If you’re curious about how AI is shaping, and challenging, the future of WordPress development and product businesses, this episode is for you.

Useful links

WS Form

Categories
Uncategorized

Matt: New TLDs

For the first time since 2012, there’s a new round of TLDs being created by ICANN, and we just had string confirmation day!

I’m happy to share that Automattic is uncontested for .jazz, .php, .soul, .wordpress, .tumblr, .woo, and I personally got .matt.

We have really enjoyed shepherding .blog which has turned into a nice option with a pretty clean namespace (that’s why we have premium prices on renewal, not just registration) and it’s had some high profile adoption, for example github.blog, stackoverflow.blog, seths.blog (Seth Godin), tim.blog (Tim Ferriss), noahpinion.blog (Noah Smith), steve.blog (Steve Jurvetson), and mgs.blog (M.G. Siegler) and ~ 395,000 more. 🤠

You can see all the still contested TLDs here.

Categories
Uncategorized

Open Channels FM: Finding Your Edge as the Web Ecosystem Evolves

Remkus de Vries shares how agencies and professionals can adapt to industry changes and take charge of their business direction.

Categories
Uncategorized

Thanksgiving dinner is likely to be served with a side of political disagreement

Turkey’s good; how’s the conversation? Jay L. Clendenin/Los Angeles Times via Getty Images

Every year as Thanksgiving approaches, news stories are written about how holiday gatherings bring together people who see the world very differently, sometimes leading to uncomfortable dinner conversations. The stories usually include advice about avoiding awkward moments and topics that are off-limits, and navigating heated conversations if they arise.

As experts in health communication and public health, we are keenly aware of how conversations with family members and close friends shape people’s decisions and actions and that sometimes the benefits of having difficult conversations outweigh the potential costs. We wondered how often difficult conversations actually take place at Thanksgiving meals and what the conversations are about.

Although studies have demonstrated that Thanksgiving meals involving people with diverse political viewpoints were shorter by 24 minutes than meals among people holding similar views, we found no estimates of how often these conversations occur.

Our survey of 354 adults from 17 states found that over half – 57% – will share a Thanksgiving meal this year with at least one person from outside their household who sees the world very differently than they do. In 4 out of 5 of these cases, the way their viewpoints differ is politics.

The survey participants were initially recruited to represent differing perspectives on health; they were not randomly selected to represent the general population. That means the survey’s findings may not be generalizable beyond the study sample.

Table talk: What do Americans expect this Thanksgiving?

From Nov. 7-9, 2026, we surveyed 354 adults from 17 states about their plans for this year’s Thanksgiving. Respondents were part of an ongoing health knowledge monitoring and response system. Their mean age was 47.1 years; three-quarters of them were women; and they were racially and ethnically diverse, with 44% white, 33% African American, 15% Hispanic ethnicity and 8% another race or ethnicity. About 1 in 10 were rural residents, and 43% had children under 18 living in their home.

The questions about Thanksgiving meals were sent to 430 people on Nov. 7; 354 completed a survey, which is an 82% response rate.

Of the 354 respondents, 80% expected to share a meal with family members or friends from outside their household during the upcoming Thanksgiving holiday.

Those planning to share a meal with others from outside their household were then asked, “Holiday meals sometimes bring together people from different generations, with different views, or different life experiences. Thinking about your upcoming Thanksgiving meal, will anyone be there who sees the world very differently than you do?”

Almost 71% of those planning to share a meal with others outside their household said yes.

Asked “What are those differences about?” by far the most common response was politics, at 81%, followed by religion at almost 58%, differing views about people such as their career choices or relationships at 54%, health at 53%; and half of the respondents said money. A few mentioned other differences such as “raising children” and “parenting” and “gender expression” and “LGBTQ.”

Asked if they think any of those differences will be expressed during the meal, almost 60% said yes. This was especially true for differences in politics. A large majority – 79% – of respondents said that differences in politics would be expressed during the meal. Fewer respondents – 40% or less – expected that differences in views about people, money, religion or health would be expressed.

Then our questions got to who is expected to disagree – and what respondents anticipate the disagreements will be about. These responses varied by race and ethnicity.

White respondents were more likely than African American or Hispanic respondents to say that others at their Thanksgiving meal will view politics differently from them. African American respondents were more likely than White or Hispanic respondents to say that others at their meal will view money matters differently and were more likely than Hispanics to say that others at their meal will view certain people differently.

In short, it’s highly common for those gathered around any Thanksgiving table this year to have different views on key matters, but the differences you’re most likely to hear about during mealtime conversation are political.

The value in disagreeing

Science tells us that conflict resolution improves through dialogue by reducing stereotypes and changing attitudes that tend to divide people. Holiday meals could provide some clues about how Americans navigate conversations with those who hold different viewpoints from them on politics, religion, money and health.

As one panel member commented: “I don’t keep people around just because they agree with me on something. I don’t cut people away because we disagree about something.”

Tori De La Vega contributed to this story.

The Conversation

Matthew W. Kreuter receives funding from the National Institutes of Health.

Kimberly Johnson and Rachel Garg do not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organization that would benefit from this article, and have disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.

​Politics + Society – The Conversation

Categories
Uncategorized

Matt: Who Wrote What

The debates and fire around authorship are playing out faster in literature and other languages than you may be aware of. The best summation of this so far is Brunella Tipismana Urbano’s translated from Spanish essay The Part About the Machines.

The role of intellectuals is to shed light on these crossroads, to, as George Scialabba once wrote, understand their contemporary moral and political significance for the present with singular originality and force. And yet, confronted with a genuinely new phenomenon, our intellectuals have chosen to close their eyes. They have happily chosen ignorance.

Categories
Uncategorized

US foreign policy leaders say America should take an active role in world affairs – but no consensus on whether Trump’s policies are working

President Donald Trump and Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth salute as U.S. Army members move a transfer case containing the remains of Pvt. Isabella Gonzales, killed in Iranian strike on Jordan, on July 22, 2026, at Dover Air Force Base, Del. AP Photo/Matt Rourke

In the wake of the U.S. midterms, Vice President JD Vance blamed the Iran war for the election result. Affordability, Vance pointed out, appeared to be central to voters’ choices, with foreign policy decisions such as the Iran war generating higher fuel prices and rates of inflation. Polling before the election confirmed voters’ concerns – nearly two-thirds of Americans disapproved of President Donald Trump’s foreign policy.

But do foreign policy experts share Americans’ concerns?

To answer that question, the University of Texas at Austin, in partnership with the the Chicago Council on Global Affairs, recently surveyed 449 U.S. foreign policy leaders from the executive branch, Congress, think tanks, interest groups, media and academia.

Their responses matter because as the United States struggles to end the Iran war and navigate the fallout of tariff policies, these experts will be tasked with finding solutions to those pressing problems. These foreign policy experts are also likely to be advising presidential candidates in the run-up to the 2028 elections.

Areas of consensus and disagreement

On some issues, there is a consensus.

We found strong bipartisan agreement on the need for the U.S. to take an active role in the world, the importance of supporting NATO, and the use of force to support European allies if they are attacked.

Ninety-three percent of experts want the United States to take an active part in the world. That includes 83% of Republican experts, 98% of Democrats and 90% of independents. More than 70% of Democrats and more than 80% of Republicans and independents among foreign policy experts we surveyed agree that military power has been very important to American influence in the world. And more than 90% of experts of all partisan stripes agree that economic power has been very important.

However, these points of agreement mask key differences.

On the Iran war, 98% of Democrats and 73% of independent experts say war was the wrong decision, while 58% of Republican leaders say it was correct. While experts of all stripes recognized that tariffs would raise costs for Americans, there were stronger splits on whether tariffs were good for the U.S. economy. One hundred percent of Democrats and 81% of independents say they were bad, while 53% of Republicans say they were good.

America First

These answers largely rally around partisan identities, but responses to philosophical questions about how the U.S. should pursue its interests proved more varied.

The Trump administration has challenged the foundations of U.S. foreign policy through its America First agenda, which favors U.S. domestic and economic interests over international agreements and global alliances.

Protestors with placards walk on a city street.
A South Korean protester takes part in a protest against President Donald Trump’s tariff policy on South Korea near the U.S. Embassy in Seoul on Oct. 7, 2026.
AP Photo/Ahn Young-joon

On tariffs, efforts to expand U.S. territory and the use of force, the Trump administration used coercion to achieve its ends, including with close allies.

The Biden administration used tariffs to counter China’s dominance in areas such as critical minerals and batteries. The Trump administration has applied tariffs to rivals such as China and traditional allies alike, including in Europe and Asia.

The Trump administration also expressed interest in territorial expansion through the acquisition of Greenland and even Canada as a possible 51st state.

Besides military operations to depose and capture the Venezuelan president and war with Iran, the Trump administration has struck boats in the Caribbean suspected of running drugs.

The downsides of coercion

We asked foreign policy leaders to assess the sources of U.S. power and whether there are downsides to a coercive strategy of American dominance. Specifically, we asked them: “In order to achieve U.S. foreign policy goals internationally, do you think it is more important for the U.S. to be feared or admired around the world?”

Sixty-two percent of Republican leaders suggested it is more important to be feared, while 97% of Democrats said it’s more important to be admired. Independents were closer to Democrats, with 81% saying it’s better to be admired.

We also asked whether countries have options to oppose U.S. coercion: “The Trump administration has used coercion, tariffs, punitive sanctions, and threats against many other countries, including traditional allies,” we said. Then we asked, “Which of these best captures your view?”

The respondents had three options to choose from. Thirty-nine percent of Republican experts agreed that “Other countries largely have to accept what the U.S. dictates.” No Democrats and 11% of independents agreed with that sentiment.

Fifty-five percent of Democrats and 54% of independents chose the second option: “Other countries will accept what the U.S. dictates in the short run but will distance themselves from United States order in the longer run.” A large percentage of Republicans – 48% – agreed with that sentiment. This suggests a recognition by Republicans that coercive power alone may have its limits.

A further 44% of Democrats and 35% of independents chose option three, “Other countries have viable options in the short and long run to resist U.S. coercion,” compared to only 13% of Republicans.

These partisan gaps suggest some strong cleavages about the foundations of U.S. power in the world. They also raise questions about how best the U.S. can achieve its interests on the world stage.

A subsequent U.S. president may have to engage in more vigorous dialogue with the American public about the sources of U.S. influence and power. The Trump administration’s coercive turn has some adherents, but many leaders see major costs to that approach and may be open to a new approach to U.S. foreign policy.

Enough damage to the existing world order has been done by the Trump administration, we believe, that a return to establishment internationalism of old is not an option.

Our survey suggests a ripe moment for new ideas and wide-ranging conversation about the U.S. role in the world.

The Conversation

Joshua Busby received funding from the University of Texas-Austin for this project. He is a senior nonresident fellow with the Chicago Council on Global Affairs.

Jonathan Monten and Jordan Tama do not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organization that would benefit from this article, and have disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.

​Politics + Society – The Conversation

Categories
Uncategorized

Forms, phone calls and portals: The hidden work that keeps American institutions functioning burdens parents most

Life administration hits some groups harder than others. sturti/E+ via Getty Images

As a working mom of three kids, I spend a lot of time parenting. I also spend a lot of time coordinating insurance, physician and school forms and remembering passwords to six different school and sports portals. None of that is really parenting, and it’s not paid work either, but it takes time away from both.

I’m also a political theorist who studies how institutional design affects people’s daily lives. What many people characterize as unavoidable aspects of modern life actually provide important lessons about how various institutions are set up and who does the work to keep them functional.

Which institutions?

Most American families deal with multiple complex institutions every week: a personalized mix of health insurers and medical providers, schools, tax authorities, Social Security and benefits agencies, daycares and camps and other kid activities, and state and federal programs such as Medicaid or SNAP.

Each of these programs has its own logic, including specific rules, portals, databases, forms, deadlines and definitions. This variation creates subtle misalignments across programs that compound over time. The physician needs prior authorization from the insurer, but the insurer claims the doctor needs a specific form. Meanwhile, the school needs the doctor’s document, and a benefits office might need proof that another agency already has in its system.

The people working to align all these systems are parents, often people with the least time and cognitive availability to handle the burden.

pen lying on permission slip
Parents especially can feel they’re drowning in portals and permission forms as they coordinate family needs.
alexskopje/iStock via Getty Images Plus

Political scientists Pamela Herd and Donald Moynihan of the Better Government Lab call this load administrative burden; that burden includes learning all the rules, figuring out how to comply with them, and then handling all the rippling demands that each individual task creates.

These burdens are not natural or inevitable. Instead, they’re the result of the way people have designed our institutions. The good news is that it’s possible to do things differently.

How did we get here?

Most institutions weren’t intentionally designed with the user experience in mind. Instead, they’re the result of piecemeal decisions over decades, often the result of a complex interplay of interest-group lobbying, political jockeying and public demands.

Employer-based health insurance resulted, in part, from fear of socialized medicine during World War II. Public schools grew out of local communities and then had layers of state and federal regulations piled on top. Bureaucracies at different levels and of different types rarely talk to each other or bother coordinating their rules and processes.

And most of these rules and processes aren’t usually nefarious in intent. Documentation can prevent fraud, eligibility rules help allocate scarce resources, regulations can protect patients, and institutions have a vested interest in protecting themselves from mistakes and liability.

But each operates in isolation. The cracks are visible only to the person who has to navigate these silos – and that’s often an overextended parent.

Who pays (more)?

It might seem like everyone bears the same administrative burdens, but they don’t. Life administration hits some groups harder than others; women, people with disabilities and lower-income people all interact more frequently with these fragmented systems and are less able to absorb the costs of those interactions.

For a middle-class American on salary, an hour on hold is a nuisance. For a waitress working for tips, it’s lost earnings or even lost employment. For many Americans, the administrative burden of applying for and proving eligibility for benefits is dramatic; the people who need these programs the most struggle to access them.

This is what researchers call a regressive effect in public policy, meaning that the costs hit hardest for those who can least afford it. Many institutions are effectively means-tested in reverse: The most vulnerable pay the most in terms of time, energy and money.

exterior facade of a multistory building with American flag flying on pole
Institutions can feel set in stone, but people can design them in more accessible and logical ways.
Nico Raddatz/iStock via Getty Images Plus

How to align fragmented systems

While there is no easy fix with institutions as complex as healthcare, education or public benefits, there are some options.

One useful model is universal design: the idea that we should build our environments – in this case, institutions – for people of different abilities from the start.

On the institutional front, this would mean more flexible hours to accommodate a range of users; a combination of email, phone and platform access; automatic enrollment or renewal when eligibility is already known; various plain language rules; and agencies sharing information, with permission, and working together to resolve conflicts between policies and rules so families aren’t forced into the role of unpaid institutional coordinators. Much of this will require not just language rewrites but significant investment in new systems.

Michigan provides an example of reform working at scale. In 2018 the state consolidated benefit application forms across five programs, reducing length and complexity. The original combined application packet was an overwhelming 1,000 questions and over 64 pages long.

The streamlined application process, which could be completed in about 20 minutes, not only improved the process for those applying. It reduced errors, cut down worker processing time and saved caseworkers 200,000 hours per year, presumably saving tax dollars along the way. Reducing administrative burden across programs is one of the few policy reforms with almost no downside.

For now, many Americans are like fish swimming in polluted water. We know something’s wrong, but we can’t see the cause. The next time you’re stuck on hold trying to fix a paperwork error with one agency before you can submit additional paperwork to another, it’s worthwhile to remember that this experience isn’t an inevitability of modern life. It’s the result of design choices – or failure to make choices – that can be changed.

The Conversation

Lauren Hall is a Distinguished Fellow with the Institute for Humane Studies.

​Politics + Society – The Conversation

Categories
Uncategorized

Massive super PAC spending did not secure Republican victories in 2026, but it remains a pernicious influence – in both parties

A lot of money is spent to get you to vote a certain way. cmannphoto/iStock Getty Images Plus

It was almost as if all the money didn’t matter.

Republican super PACs substantially outspent Democratic ones in the 2026 midterm elections – particularly in Texas, where Elon Musk spent an astounding US$224 million on behalf of Republican Ken Paxton’s Senate campaign.

Yet Republicans lost across the board – regardless of whether they had super PAC support.

Not only did they lose, but the swing toward Democrats was remarkably consistent across the entire country, regardless of how much money was spent or what the fundraising imbalance was.

So, do the 2026 election results mean that super PAC spending, which represents the single-largest category of campaign spending in competitive races, doesn’t matter as much as we thought? Do they mean that Americans should worry less about the effect of these super PACs on politics?

As a political scientist who studies campaign spending, I would say no. Here’s why.

A person wearing a mask of another person, standing in front of a large inflatable person wearing a tuxedo, carry a fake check.
A protester mocks Elon Musk’s massive donations to the U.S. Senate campaign of Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton on Nov. 2, 2026, in Austin, Texas.
Brandon Bell/Getty Images

The limited effects of super PACs in general elections

Super PACs are political committees that engage in political advocacy but do not donate money to candidates or directly coordinate their strategies with them. Because of this, there are no limits on what super PACs can spend or on the size of the contributions they can receive.

They have limited effects on general elections. In competitive general election races for the House and Senate, it is usually the case that both candidates have significant funding, so the incremental value of each dollar declines as spending increases.

In each election cycle, approximately 90% of voters vote for the same party they did in the previous election. Voters such as these are unlikely to be moved by super PAC advertising.

Most importantly, super PAC spending is less efficient than spending by candidates or parties. By law, candidates and parties receive the “lowest unit charge,” or LUC, from television networks – that is, they pay the lowest permissible rate for advertising in a particular time slot. Super PACs do not receive the LUC, and thus they can pay two or three times as much per advertisement.

In a broader sense, however, the fact that super PACs cannot legally coordinate with candidates means that they are not able to spend money as wisely as candidates do. Usually, candidates and parties have access to the top consultants, they are likely to have information about what worked in the last election in their state or district, and they often have targeting information about voters.

A super PAC could acquire these things, but it cannot acquire them from the candidates themselves. In addition, many super PACs are ephemeral – they are organized to advocate for one particular candidate or set of candidates, and they do not last more than a few months. As a consequence, they do not have the ability to learn from their past efforts.

This may have been a particular problem in Texas. The sheer volume of spending by Musk in such a short time frame meant that there was little infrastructure to support his spending – all his super PAC could do was buy a lot of relatively untargeted advertisements.

Yet despite their often crudely targeted efforts to help candidates, super PACs still are a pernicious influence in politics for four reasons.

1. Super PACs spend a tremendous amount of money

Nearly two-thirds of super PAC spending in 2026 can be traced to only 100 people. These 100 people have very narrow business interests, but few of them are as controversial as Musk.
One reason Musk’s massive spending was not helpful was that Paxton’s opponent, James Talarico, made his criticism of Musk a part of his campaign. Most super PAC donors are not as likely to provoke the sort of backlash that may have blunted Musk’s effectiveness in Texas.

Without public pushback based on an awareness of a donor’s agenda, this spending can reorient campaigns to be about the idiosyncratic ideas of an unrepresentative group of billionaires. It makes campaigns about something other than what parties, candidates and voters want them to be about. Parties and candidates, in turn, must raise more money than before just to be heard.

2. Super PACs shape elections long before November

An image of the U.S. Capitol dome, tipping sideways with paper currency floating into the inside of the building.
Most politicians, regardless of party, have become dependent on super PAC money.
iStock/Getty Images Plus

Super PACs play a major role in primary elections, where voters are choosing among candidates of the same party and cannot simply use a candidate’s party label to choose whom to vote for. Some of the most expensive elections in 2024 and 2026 were primary elections in safe districts where one party was overwhelmingly favored to win the general election.

In the 9th District of Illinois, for instance, super PACs spent $9.1 million in the Democratic primary in support of six candidates. Few voters in the 9th District knew how much had been spent, who the groups were, or even what issues motivated these groups until after the election.

Super PACs have also increased their spending in nonpartisan municipal elections, where there is little advertising or media coverage and therefore voters often have even less information about the candidates or their policies.

3. Super PACs can be a vehicle for nefarious schemes

During the 2026 midterm campaign, conservative super PACs in Ohio and Massachusetts sent out deliberately deceptive mailings highlighting obscure socialist candidates, aiming to siphon votes away from the Democrats these groups were really concerned about.

While politics can often be dirty and these mailings were not illegal, they enable the candidates these groups supported to claim they have nothing to do with them. A candidate, a party or an established interest group has a reputation to protect, and voters can hold them accountable for the quality of their campaigns. Super PACs do not have to worry about this because they do not appear on the ballot, and they do not have members or stockholders who can put pressure on them.

4. Super PAC spending can affect how legislators behave

Even legislators with very safe seats must constantly worry about whether one vote, or one statement, might cause someone to spend a large sum of money against them. Many legislators cast votes they know their constituents will dislike in order to avoid antagonizing groups that might spend against them in their primary.

It’s legal, if deplored, by the public

Most Americans want limits on super PAC spending.

Many Democratic candidates in 2026 called for campaign finance reforms. It is tempting to believe that the new Democratic majorities in Congress will do something to rein in super PACs. There are many obstacles to doing so, however.

For one, the Supreme Court is unlikely to change its views on the legality of independent spending. The justices have decreed it is speech, and they see no constitutional restraint on this kind of speech.

While voters support campaign finance reform, they rarely list it as their top priority. And although Republicans benefited more from super PAC spending in 2026 than Democrats, many Democratic candidates have been dependent on it as well. The Democrats’ comfortable majority may make it easier than before for Democrats to receive more super PAC support.

Although super PAC support did not propel Republicans to victory in 2026, the real danger of super PACs is that most politicians, regardless of party, have become dependent upon them.

The Conversation

Robert Boatright does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organization that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.

​Politics + Society – The Conversation