Categories
Uncategorized

ICE not only looks and acts like a paramilitary force – it is one, and that makes it harder to curb

As the operations of Immigration and Customs Enforcement have intensified over the past year, politicians and journalists alike have begun referring to ICE as a “paramilitary force.”

Rep. John Mannion, a New York Democrat, called ICE “a personal paramilitary unit of the president.” Journalist Radley Balko, who wrote a book about how American police forces have been militarized, has argued that President Donald Trump was using the force “the way an authoritarian uses a paramilitary force, to carry out his own personal grudges, to inflict pain and violence, and discomfort on people that he sees as his political enemies.” And New York Times columnist Jamelle Bouie characterized ICE as a “virtual secret police” and “paramilitary enforcer of despotic rule.”

All this raises a couple of questions: What are paramilitaries? And is ICE one?

Defining paramilitaries

As a government professor who studies policing and state security forces, I believe it’s clear that ICE meets many but not all of the most salient definitions. It’s worth exploring what those are and how the administration’s use of ICE compares with the ways paramilitaries have been deployed in other countries.

The term paramilitary is commonly used in two ways. The first refers to highly militarized police forces, which are an official part of a nation’s security forces. They typically have access to military-grade weaponry and equipment, are highly centralized with a hierarchical command structure, and deploy in large formed units to carry out domestic policing.

These “paramilitary police,” such as the French Gendarmerie, India’s Central Reserve Police Force or Russia’s Internal Troops, are modeled on regular military forces.

The second definition denotes less formal and often more partisan armed groups that operate outside of the state’s regular security sector. Sometimes these groups, as with the United Self-Defense Forces of Colombia, emerge out of community self-defense efforts; in other cases, they are established by the government or receive government support, even though they lack official status. Political scientists also call these groups “pro-government militias” in order to convey both their political orientation in support of the government and less formal status as an irregular force.

Heavily armed and masked security personnel enter a home.
Indian paramilitary personnel conduct a house-to-house search in Kashmir.
AP Photo/Mukhtar Khan

They typically receive less training than regular state forces, if any. How well equipped they are can vary a great deal. Leaders may turn to these informal or unofficial paramilitaries because they are less expensive than regular forces, or because they can help them evade accountability for violent repression.

Many informal paramilitaries are engaged in regime maintenance, meaning they preserve the power of current rulers through repression of political opponents and the broader public. They may share partisan affiliations or ethnic ties with prominent political leaders or the incumbent political party and work in tandem to carry out political goals.

In Haiti, President François “Papa Doc” Duvalier’s Tonton Macouts provided a prime example of this second type of paramilitary. After Duvalier survived a coup attempt in 1970, he established the Tonton Macouts as a paramilitary counterweight to the regular military. Initially a ragtag, undisciplined but highly loyal force, it became the central instrument through which the Duvalier regime carried out political repression, surveilling, harassing, detaining, torturing and killing ordinary Haitians.

Is ICE a paramilitary?

The recent references to ICE in the U.S. as a “paramilitary force” are using the term in both senses, viewing the agency as both a militarized police force and tool for repression.

There is no question that ICE fits the definition of a paramilitary police force. It is a police force under the control of the federal government, through the Department of Homeland Security, and it is heavily militarized, having adopted the weaponry, organization, operational patterns and cultural markers of the regular military. Some other federal forces, such as Customs and Border Patrol, or CBP, also fit this definition.

The data I have collected on state security forces show that approximately 30% of countries have paramilitary police forces at the federal or national level, while more than 80% have smaller militarized units akin to SWAT teams within otherwise civilian police.

The United States is nearly alone among established democracies in creating a new paramilitary police force in recent decades. Indeed, the creation of ICE in the U.S. following the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11, 2001, is one of just four instances I’ve found since 1960 where a democratic country created a new paramilitary police force, the others being Honduras, Brazil and Nigeria.

A group of uniformed ICE personnel walk along cars in a bike lane.
ICE agents on patrol near the scene of the fatal shooting of Renee Good in Minneapolis.
AP Photo/John Locher

ICE and CBP also have some, though not all, of the characteristics of a paramilitary in the second sense of the term, referring to forces as repressive political agents. These forces are not informal; they are official agents of the state. However, their officers are less professional, receive less oversight and are operating in more overtly political ways than is typical of both regular military forces and local police in the United States.

The lack of professionalism predates the current administration. In 2014, for instance, CBP’s head of internal affairs described the lowering of standards for post-9/11 expansion as leading to the recruitment of thousands of officers “potentially unfit to carry a badge and gun.”

This problem has only been exacerbated by the rapid expansion undertaken by the Trump administration. ICE has added approximately 12,000 new recruits – more than doubling its size in less than a year – while substantially cutting the length of the training they receive.

ICE and CBP are not subject to the same constitutional restrictions that apply to other law enforcement agencies, such as the Fourth Amendment’s prohibition on unreasonable search and seizure; both have gained exemptions from oversight intended to hold officers accountable for excessive force. CBP regulations, for instance, allow it to search and seize people’s property without a warrant or the “probable cause” requirement imposed on other forces within 100 miles, or about 161 kilometers, of the border.

In terms of partisan affiliations, Trump has cultivated immigration security forces as political allies, an effort that appears to have been successful. In 2016, the union that represents ICE officers endorsed Trump’s campaign with support from more than 95% of its voting members. Today, ICE recruitment efforts increasingly rely on far-right messaging to appeal to political supporters.

Both ICE and CBP have been deployed against political opponents in nonimmigration contexts, including Black Lives Matter protests in Washington, D.C., and Portland, Oregon, in 2020. They have also gathered data, according to political scientist Elizabeth F. Cohen, to “surveil citizens’ political beliefs and activities – including protest actions they have taken on issues as far afield as gun control – in addition to immigrants’ rights.”

In these ways, ICE and CBP do bear some resemblance to the informal paramilitaries used in many countries to carry out political repression along partisan and ethnic lines, even though they are official agents of the state.

Why this matters

An extensive body of research shows that more militarized forms of policing are associated with higher rates of police violence and rights violations, without reducing crime or improving officer safety.

Studies have also found that more militarized police forces are harder to reform than less-militarized law enforcement agencies. The use of such forces can also create tensions with both the regular military and civilian police, as currently appears to be happening with ICE in Minneapolis.

The ways in which federal immigration forces in the United States resemble informal paramilitaries in other countries – operating with less effective oversight, less competent recruits and increasingly entrenched partisan identity – make all these issues more intractable. Which is why, I believe, many commentators have surfaced the term paramilitary and are using it as a warning.

The Conversation

Erica De Bruin does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organization that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.

​Politics + Society – The Conversation

Categories
Food

The 5 Best New Aldi Groceries You Can’t Miss In February 2026

We have the Super Bowl, Valentine’s Day, and more to look forward to in February, so here are the best new Aldi groceries to help celebrate.

​Food Republic – Restaurants, Reviews, Recipes, Cooking Tips

Categories
Entertainment

Skinny Jeans Are SO Back—Shop Our Fave Denim Styles From $18

skinnyjeansthumbnail.jpgJokes aside, 2026 really is shaping up to look a lot like 2016 and the skinny jean revival is just further evidence of that. 
The denim trend we swore would stay in the the 2010s is creeping back…
​E! Online (US) – Top Stories

Categories
Entertainment

Bill Cosby Admits to Obtaining 7 Quaalude Prescriptions With the Intention of Drugging …

Reading Time: 2 minutes

Though he was briefly imprisoned for drugging and raping women, Bill Cosby maintains that he’s innocent of those charges.

In a new deposition, however, Cosby admits that he obtained a prescription for Quaaludes with the intention of using the pills to drug women

He also admitted to refilling that prescription seven times.

Actor and comedian Bill Cosby returns to the courtroom after a break with his spokesman Andrew Wyatt at the Montgomery County Courthouse, during his sexual assault trial sentencing in Norristown, Pennsylvania, U.S. September 24, 2018.
Actor and comedian Bill Cosby returns to the courtroom after a break with his spokesman Andrew Wyatt at the Montgomery County Courthouse, during his sexual assault trial sentencing in Norristown, Pennsylvania, U.S. September 24, 2018. (Photo by David Maialetti-Pool/Getty Images)

Cosby maintains, however, that he never followed through with his plan to drug women.

He also says that he never took the drug himself.

This information came to light in a deposition Cosby gave in connection with a lawsuit filed by one of his accusers, a woman named Donna Motsinger.

In documents obtained by TMZ, Cosby states that he got the prescription from a doctor friend with whom he played poker in the 1970s.

In this handout image provided by the Montgomery County Correctional Facility, Bill Cosby poses for a mugshot on September 25, 2018 in Eagleville, Pennsylvania.
In this handout image provided by the Montgomery County Correctional Facility, Bill Cosby poses for a mugshot on September 25, 2018 in Eagleville, Pennsylvania. (Photo by Montgomery County Correctional Facility via Getty Images)

The doctor is reportedly an OBGYN named Dr. Leroy Amar, who had his license revoked in 1979.

But in 1972, when he attended the poker game hosted by Cosby, he was still able to write prescriptions.

And apparently that’s exactly what he did.

Again, Cosby does not deny getting the prescription, but he insists he never drugged Motsinger or anyone else.

Bill Cosby departs the Montgomery County Courthouse after a preliminary hearing, May 24, 2016, in Norristown, Pennsylvania.
Bill Cosby departs the Montgomery County Courthouse after a preliminary hearing, May 24, 2016, in Norristown, Pennsylvania. (Photo by Matt Rourke-Pool/Getty Images)

In her own testimony, Motsinger says that Cosby gave her a round white pill and told her it was Aspirin.

She says she began to slip in and out of consciousness and awoke the following morning to find that her clothes had been removed.

Court documents say that the pills obtained by Cosby were white and round, like the ones Motsinger describes.

The victim and plaintiff reportedly met when she was a server at the well-known Trident restaurant in Sausalito, California.

Cosby denies any wrongdoing and is trying to have the case thrown out of court.

We will have further updates on this developing story as new information becomes available.

Bill Cosby Admits to Obtaining 7 Quaalude Prescriptions With the Intention of Drugging … was originally published on The Hollywood Gossip.

​The Hollywood Gossip

Categories
Entertainment

Before You Order, Ask Your Server About This For The Best Meal

If you ever find yourself facing choice anxiety when ordering at a restaurant, there’s a simple question you can ask the server to make your decision easier.

​Mashed – Fast Food, Celebrity Chefs, Grocery, Reviews

Categories
Music

Lainey Wilson Documentary Coming To Netflix: Here’s the Details

The new documentary promises to explore the ups and downs of Lainey Wilson’s life and career. Continue reading…​Country Music News – Taste of Country

Categories
Music

Lainey Wilson Documentary Coming To Netflix: Here’s the Details

The new documentary promises to explore the ups and downs of Lainey Wilson’s life and career. Continue reading…​The Boot – Country Music News, Music Videos and Songs

Categories
Entertainment

Nicki Minaj: I Am Donald Trump’s Number 1 Fan!

Reading Time: 3 minutes

Who is Donald Trump’s biggest fan?

According to Nicki Minaj, it’s none other than Nicki Minaj.

Following her cringe sit-down with Erika Kirk and her more recent homophobic tirade at Don Lemon, this is no longer a surprise.

But getting invited up to the podium to speak at a US Treasury event was a surprise — even to Minaj herself.

Nicki Minaj at a podium by Donald Trump.
Next to Donald Trump on stage, Nicki Minaj addresses the room. (Image Credit: C-SPAN)

She began at a loss for words (but it all went south from there)

On Wednesday, January 28, Minaj attended an event for the US Treasury to to promote something called “Trump Accounts.”

Standing at the podium, Trump gushed about the rapper and how much money she allegedly makes.

He then invited Minaj to join him on the stage.

This was, it seems, as unplanned as a doddering old man getting up mid-conversation to stare out a window at a construction project.

At first, Minaj seemed to be unsure of what to say. Soon, however, she came up with a crowd-pleaser.

“I am probably the president’s number one fan,” Minaj raved.

“And,” she vowed, “that is not going to change.”

You know what? We believe that it’s not going to change.

“The ‘hate’ does not affect me,” Minaj announced in what we’re sure that she imagined was a defiant tone.

She then taunted: “It actually motivates me to support him more.”

Donald Trump and Nicki Minaj hold hands.
Donald Trump invited Nicki Minaj to join him on stage, to the surprise of everyone present. (Image Credit: C-SPAN)

‘I’m gonna let those nails grow’

Donald Trump doesn’t seem to know much about the singer or her music.

(And, honestly, when did she last release a bop or even a song worth knowing about?)

However, he gushed in appreciation for Minaj’s nails.

“I said, ‘I’m gonna let my nails grow,’ because I love those nails,” he told the audience. “I’m gonna let those nails grow.”

We don’t expect him to follow through. However, given that MAGA folks were wearing diapers in defiance of criticism of Trump a couple of years ago, we briefly allow ourselves to picture diehard MAGA men wearing long nails just like their beloved leader.

Nicki Minaj and Donald Trump on stage.
Standing beside a beaming Donald Trump, Nicki Minaj makes an awkward departure from the stage. (Image Credit: C-SPAN)

Obviously, a lot of people have questions about Minaj’s seemingly sudden shift to the fringe right of American politics.

She famously chatted with Christian nationalist Erika Kirk and cannot seem to stop raving about Trump.

Some believe that this is a simple right-wing grift, which we’ve seen countless times before.

Others believe that this is about Minaj’s citizenship (or lack thereof) or about her registered sex offender husband or about her imprisoned sexual predator brother.

Becoming a sycophant in exchange for political favors is the sort of bold-faced corruption that’s pretty standard in MAGA world. However, Minaj’s whole situation doesn’t seem that simple.

What happened to Nicki Minaj?

As hard as this is to say, especially for those of us who were fans of some of her music (albeit many years ago), we don’t think that Minaj herself has really changed. This is who she is, and who she was.

We linked that Matt Bernstein piece above because it is a thorough and informative rundown of why a once-celebrated music star is now shilling for MAGA world like a sub-par swimmer.

But Minaj has always been the sort of woman to pull up the ladder behind her when it comes to other women in her industry. And yes, there have been red flags about her being surprisingly anti-LGBTQ+ for years.

Maybe some things recently — the predators in her life, her weird beef with Gavin Newsom (nobody likes the guy but her reason is weird), and her anti-vax nonsense — have pushed her further into this abyss. But this is who she is.

Minaj built her fanbase primarily upon Black queer fans. She’s now done with them, and is publicly singing the praises of their enemies.

Nicki Minaj: I Am Donald Trump’s Number 1 Fan! was originally published on The Hollywood Gossip.

​The Hollywood Gossip

Categories
Music

Could Taylor Swift Join the Country Music Hall of Fame in 2026?

It’s a pretty safe bet that Taylor Swift will join the Country Music Hall of Fame someday, but if she joins in 2026, she’ll be the first to ever do so in her first year of eligibility. Continue reading…​Country Music News – Taste of Country

Categories
Music

Could Taylor Swift Join the Country Music Hall of Fame in 2026?

It’s a pretty safe bet that Taylor Swift will join the Country Music Hall of Fame someday, but if she joins in 2026, she’ll be the first to ever do so in her first year of eligibility. Continue reading…​The Boot – Country Music News, Music Videos and Songs